Conferences in India.

The post by Dr. Patta Radhakrishna, written a year ago, provides a satirical and critical commentary on the state of medical education and conferences in India. Below is a point-wise elaboration of the key observations and critiques presented in the post:

  1. Proliferation of Medical Conferences:
  • There has been a significant increase in medical conferences across India, with frequent knowledge-sharing events in various fields of medicine and surgery.
  • These conferences are characterized by an influx of speakers covering every conceivable medical topic, indicating a high level of activity in medical education.
  1. Emergence of a New Breed of Speakers:
  • A new group of professional speakers has emerged, frequently invited to speak at conferences across the country.
  • Their travel schedules are described as resembling the extensive air network of IndiGo Airlines, suggesting constant movement between cities for speaking engagements.
  • These speakers are often on the move, rarely spending time in their hometowns, raising questions about whether they maintain an active medical practice or primarily focus on speaking.
  1. Lifestyle of Speakers:
  • The speakers often enjoy lavish treatment, including gala dinners with drinks and entertainment in various cities, implying a glamorous lifestyle associated with their roles.
  • Their frequent travel and engagements suggest limited time for patient care, with the focus shifting toward conference participation.
  1. Specialized Conference Organizers:
  • A subset of doctors has specialized in organizing medical conferences, taking on roles such as organizing secretaries, treasurers, or chairmen in different cities.
  • These organizers often rotate roles across conferences, forming a network of professionals who manage and benefit from these events.
  1. Repetition of Content:
  • Many speakers deliver the same presentations, using identical slides, repeatedly across multiple conferences (e.g., over 100 times in a year).
  • The speaker lineups tend to remain consistent, with the same group of speakers appearing together at various events, suggesting a closed circle of presenters.
  1. Presence of Doctors on Domestic Flights:
  • Domestic flights in India frequently carry two distinct groups of doctors:
    • Speakers: Constantly traveling to deliver talks at conferences.
    • Corporate Doctors: Attending camps in distant cities to attract patients to their parent hospitals, aiming to boost hospital revenue and personal income.
  1. Profitability of Conferences:
  • Medical conferences have become highly profitable for organizers, with delegate packages including conference registration, hotel accommodation, gala dinners, sightseeing tours, and fellowship certificates.
  • These packages come at a high cost, often subsidized by pharmaceutical companies, which benefit from increased visibility and influence among doctors.
  1. Role of Pharmaceutical Companies:
  • Drug companies frequently sponsor conferences by covering travel, accommodation, and registration costs for delegates from various parts of India.
  • This sponsorship model benefits organizers (increased attendance), sponsors (marketing opportunities), and delegates (subsidized participation), creating a mutually beneficial ecosystem.
  1. Delegate Experience:
  • For delegates, conferences serve as both professional and recreational events, offering opportunities for networking, entertainment (music, dance, and food), and limited learning.
  • The focus is often on the social and leisure aspects rather than purely academic pursuits, with learning being secondary for many attendees.
  1. Prerequisites for Joining the Speaker Circuit:
    • To become a sought-after speaker, one must first be a conference organizer, inviting other speakers to their events to secure reciprocal invitations.
    • This creates a cycle where organizers and speakers mutually benefit by inviting each other to conferences across the country.
    • Many organizers aim for leadership roles in medical or surgical societies, using their conference involvement as a stepping stone.
  2. Critique of Non-Organizers:
    • Doctors who lack the ability or opportunity to organize conferences are unlikely to join this elite speaker circuit and must remain content with their regular medical practice.
    • These doctors may only experience conferences vicariously through social media posts or occasional glimpses of the entertainment at these events.
  3. Satirical Take on Medical Education:
    • The post sarcastically dismisses complaints about inadequate medical teaching in India, calling them “humbug.”
    • It implies that the current conference culture prioritizes networking, profit, and entertainment over genuine knowledge dissemination.
  4. Socioeconomic Impact:
    • The conference ecosystem indirectly benefits airlines, hotels, and other service providers due to the frequent travel and accommodation needs of speakers and delegates.
    • The commercialization of medical conferences highlights a shift from pure academic pursuits to a blend of professional, social, and commercial activities.

Overall Tone and Critique:

  • Dr. Radhakrishna’s post uses humor and satire to critique the commercialization and performative nature of medical conferences in India. It highlights how these events have evolved into profitable enterprises with significant involvement from pharmaceutical companies, often at the expense of authentic medical education. The post suggests a disconnect between the stated goals of knowledge sharing and the reality of networking, entertainment, and career advancement for a select group of organizers and speakers.

Leave a comment