l of Medicin
zwyvxuwtsvruqtpsornmqp Depression in Epilepsy: Etiology, Phenomenology,
0International League Against Epilepsy
Summary: A history of depression or depressive symptom- atology has been reported in up to two-thirds of patients with medically intractable epilepsy, whereas community studies have demonstrated affective disorder only in a quarter of these patients. Depression has been reported peri- and interictally. However, differentiation may be difficult in patients with fre- quent seizures. Most authors have found no correlation between depression and epilepsy variables. However, complex partial seizures, especially of temporal lobe origin, appear to be etio- logic factors, particularly in men with left-sided foci. Depres- sion is also more common in patients treated with polytherapy especially with barbiturates, phenytoin, and vigabatrin. Depres-
sion has also been described de novo after temporal lobectomy. Psychosocial factors also play a part, but underlying risk factors (e.g., genetic, endocrine and metabolic) may explain the in- creased rates of depression in people with epilepsy compared to those with other neurologic and chronic medical conditions.
The association between epilepsy and depression has been known since antiquity. In the Hippocratic corpus, written around 400 B.c., it is stated:
melancholics ordinarily become epileptics, and epileptics melancholics: what determines the preference is the direc- tion the malady takes; if it bears upon the body, epilepsy, if upon the intelligence, melancholy ( 1).
The importance of recognizing depression in people with epilepsy is not only to enable appropriate treatment to be considered but also to identify patients at risk for suicide. The reported incidence of suicide and deliberate self harm varies considerably from series to series but is be- lieved to be at least four to five times that of the general population (2,3), and patients with temporal lobe epi- lepsy (TLE) are at increased risk by a factor of up to 25 (23). Robertson (4) reviewed 17 studies detailing
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Prof. M. M.
Robertson at Department of Psychiatry and Behavioural Sciences, Uni-
versitv College London Medical School. 48 Riding House Street. Lon- .
don WIN SLA, U.K.
Michelle V. Lambert and *Mary M. Robertson
of Psychiatry and Behavioural Sciences, University College London Medical School, London, United Kingdom
The depression appears to be endogenous. Patients tend to ex- hibit fewer neurotic traits and more psychotic symptoms such as paranoia, delusions, and persecutory auditory hallucinations. Treatment approaches include psychotherapy, rationalization of antiepileptic drug medication, antidepressant treatment, and ECT. The tricyclic and related antidepressants appear to be epileptogenic, especially in people at high risk (personal or family history of seizures, abnormal pretreatment EEG, brain damage, alcohol or substance abuse/withdrawal and concurrent use of CNS-active medication). Seizures tend to occur early in treatment or after dose increments, especially if rapidly titrated. There is little evidence that the newer antidepressants, e.g., selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, moclobemide, venlafax- ine, or nefazodone are more epileptogenic than placebo. Key Words: Depression-Epilepsy-Antiepileptic drugs- Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors.
cause of death in patients with epilepsy and found that the average incidence of suicide was nine- to tenfold that of the general population ( 13.2% compared with 1.4%). Two reports have also shown a 5-7% increase in self- poisoning in these patients (5,6).Suicide has been re- ported in patients with severe epilepsy, epilepsy with other handicaps, and those seen in specialist clinics (4) but may also follow an improvement in seizure control (7).Increased suicide rates have also been reported after temporal lobe surgery even if the outcome was success- ful (8,9).Harris and Barraclough (3)performed a meta- analysis of follow-up studies to assess suicide rate in psychiatric and neuropsychiatric conditions. They found the highest suicide rate for patients with surgically treated TLE who had an increased risk by a factor of 80, with a standardized mortality rate (SMR) of 8,750. Risk factors for completed suicide have been found to include Drevious historv of deliberate self-harm, familv historv of suicide, stressful life events, poor morale, stigma, and psychiatric disorders and
depression, psychosis, and personality disorder (3,4).
e of Psvchia
try and GKT
e, and *
s22 zyxMw. V.LAMBERT ANvD M. M. RuOBERTSONtsrqp
One study in the general population found that half of those who committed suicide did so within 24 h after a medical consultation, many ingesting their prescribed drugs, and almost half had communicated their suicidal intent (10). Therefore, physicians should specifically consider and inquire about suicidal ideation and intent in
was the most common ictal emotion. Ictal depression appears to be more common in patients with TLE (15).in whom rates of over 10% have been reported ( 16,17). No association with laterality of seizure focus has been found (15-17).
patients with epilepsy who may be at risk for attempting
suicide. stimuli. It can occur in isolation (SPS) or within seconds
Depression in patients with epilepsy has been reported to minutes before the development of a complex partial
peri- and inter-ictally. However, in patients with frequent seizures, differentiation may be difficult.
(CPS) andlor secondarily generalized seizure. The sever-
or irritability o
hours to days before a seizure and are often relieved by
the 19th century psychiatrist Grule:
)observed d liams (15
( 11). This w
history of ictal depression who committed suicide during a cluster of CPSs. Complex (formed) hallucinations may accompany the depressive feelings. Williams ( 15) and Weil (16)reported an association between olfactory hal- lucinations and ictal depression. Interestingly, several workers have found ictal depression to be of prolonged duration, often persisting into the postictal period, which may represent underlying subclinical seizure activity (1516).
. . . physician and attendants do hope for a seizure in these often very difficult patients, which comes like a salvation for everybody: the patient is much more bearable for weeks thereafter ( 12).
Blanchet and Frommer (13) performed a prospective study examining prodromal mood changes. They found that most patients reported more depression on the days immediately preceding their seizure than on interictal days, along with improvement of mood after seizures. The phenomenology of these low moods was not docu- mented. The authors suggest several explanations for the prodromal mood changes. The low mood may be a symptom of subclinical seizure activity or of physiologic or biologic processes involved in initiation of both the lowered mood and the seizure. In some patients, how- ever, a negative, depressed or dysphoric mood in com- bination with negative life events may increase the like- lihood of seizures.
A more recent study (14) evaluated 148 adult patients
with epilepsy of whom 128 had partial seizures. Pre-
monitory symptoms were defined as behavioral phenom-
ena that preceded seizures by at least 30 min. A third of
the patients with partial seizures reported premonitory
symptoms (usually before secondarily generalized sei-
zures) compared with none of the patients with primarily
generalized epilepsy (PGE).Half of the symptoms were
emotional in nature and consisted of feelings of irritabil-
ity, depression, fear, elation, and anger. The symptoms
lasted between 10 min and 3 days, and the intensity
TREATMENT OF PRE- AND ICTAL DEPRESSION
Although prodromal and ictal depression does not usu- ally require treatment per se, improvement in seizure frequency (see below) should reduce the occurrence of these forms of depression. These depressive pre- and peri-ictal feelings may be regarded by some patients as an “early warning system.” Patients may have time to alert people that they require assistance and may also have time to move to a place of safety. Medication such as fast-acting benzodiazepines may abort or prevent the development of the attack as may behavioral methods such as stress management, biofeedback, or aroma- therapy (21-23).
Blumer (24) described three patients who developed depression lasting hours to days immediately after sei- zures. However, these patients also experienced episodes of interictal depression, and Blumer noted that it was rare to find a patient who suffered postictal depression alone.
reported a patient who attempted suicide during such an episode. Mendez and Doss (20) reported a patient with a
Ictal depression, classically, is of sudden onset and occxurs out of cwontext i.e., not revlated to envuironmental
ts hopelessness and despair ( 1 1). Lim et al. ( 18) described
PREICTAL DEPRESSION a patient with nonconvulsive status epilepticus present- ing as a case of psychotic depression, and Betts (19)
f sadness to
tended to wax and wane over this time. zyxwvDevinskyuetal.(25)atssessedthepsostictalbehraviorafterqp
ICTAL DEPRESSION CPSs in 18 patients with medically intractable depres- sion. Postictal flattened or depressed affect occurred Depression can occur as part of the ictus itself. Wil- more commonly after CPSs originating in right temporal
ccurring as p
of a series of 2,000 patients with epilepsy, although fear not appear to be consistent with those of an earlier single
Epilepsia, Vol. 4
0, Suppl. 1
seizure, SPS) in approximately 1% bilateral limbic dysfunction. However, these findings do
art of an
, and more p
mild feelings o
Interictal depression is believed to be much more com- mon than peri-ictal depression. However, the prevalence is not known. Most studies have been criticized for using nonrepresentative hospital samples, for being retrospec- tive, or for using questionnaires rather than clinical judg- ment to diagnose depression. Interpretation is further complicated by the fact that some studies have reported
depressive symptomatology whereas others reported de- pressive illness.
The major studies investigating depression in PWE are shown in Table 1 and should be compared with the prevalence of depression in the general population of 1-3% for men and 2-9% for women (45). In general, depression is more common andor more severe in pa- tients with epilepsy than in patients with other neurologic and chronic medical conditions (29,46,47). The rate of depression appears to be lowest in community studies, increasing in patients attending hospital outpatient cen-
ters, and is highest in patients with medically intractable epilepsy being evaluated for epilepsy surgery (34,48,49), although in some centers patients with severe psychiatric disorders are excluded from the epilepsy surgery pro- gram.
Some investigators have not found such high rates of depression in people with epilepsy. Fiordelli et al. (50) found that only 6% of patients with cryptogenic epilepsy in Milan had a DSM-111-R depressive disorder (depres- sive disorder NOS or dysthymia) compared with 5% of controls. However the study group could be considered atypical because only 90% of the patients had “active” epilepsy (i.e., had experienced seizures within the previ- ous 2 years) and only 28% had partial seizures of pre- sumed temporal lobe origin, reflecting the exclusion of patients with documented brain lesions.
Various causative factors have been proposed for the development of depression in people with epilepsy (Table 2). The etiology is most likely to be multifacto- rial, with several different factors playing a part in each individual patient.
A family history of depression has been reported in some studies. Robertson et al. (54) found that more than half of 66 patients with both epilepsy and depression had a family history of psychiatric illness, usually depres- sion. Others, however, have found no association (31,37, 39). Only one study has compared the incidence of psy- chiatric disorders in first-degree relatives of patients with acquired epilepsy (26 probands) with relatives of patients with genetic epilepsy, (juvenile myoclonic epilepsy, JME) (60). Depression was the most common psychiatric disorder in both probands and relatives and almost twice as many patients with JME had first-degree relatives with mental illness. The findings of this small study
case report (26) of a patient who developed postictal depression after left-sided CPSs and hypomania after right-sided seizures.
Blumer (24) has postulated that postictal depression is
a consequence of the inhibitory mechanisms involved in
the termination of seizures. He suggested that procon-
vulsant antidepressant medication (see below) in lower also found men to be over-represented in depressed pa- doses than usually prescribed, along with optimal control tients (31,46,53) and patients who deliberately harmed of the epilepsy would be the treatment of choice and themselves (6).
would be expected to work within 24 h.
Few studies have addressed this variable. However, Altshuler et al. (51) found the highest Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) scores in male patients with TLE, and Strauss et al. (52) found that men with left-sided foci were more vulnwerable to depressvion. Other authors have
(but nonsignificant) number of women to have psychiat- ric morbidity as measured using the present state exami- nation (PSE), and more women with epilepsy and de- pression have been reported by others (543.5). Still oth- ers, however, have not found gender to be a significant etiologic factor (35,39).
Although the results of the various studies are not congruent, the majority of studies that have addressed gender have found men to be most at risk. This is par- ticularly significant because studies of people with de- pression without epilepsy have demonstrated an in- creased prevalence in women.
This factor has not been intensively explored. Some studies have observed that more left-handed people with epilepsy tended to have psychiatric morbidity, especially depression (51). However, other studies have found no such association (37). The expression of left-handedness may indicate early brain injury.
Depression may be associated with a neurologic con- dition that is also responsible for the epilepsy, e.g., mul- tiple sclerosis, cerebrovascular disorder, dementia, and head injury (56,.57), and may be more common in pa- tients with a structural lesion (28,58). However, some studies have not found a structural brain lesion to be associated with depression in patients with epilepsy (31,59).
Standage and Fen
ton (29) foun
d a higher
might be explained by either genetic or environmental
hypotheses, and further studies are needed.
Epitepsru, Vol. 40, Suppl.
M. V. LAMBERT zyxwvutzsyrqxwpov
Reference Currie et al. (27)
Standage and Fenton (29) Roy (301
Mender et al. (31)
Brown et al. (32)
Edeh and Toone (33)
Edeb et al. (34)
Victoroff et al. (35) Gureje (36)
Indaco et al. (37)
Robertson et al. (39)
Manchanda et al. (40)
Jacoby et al. (41)
Baker et al. (42) Ring et al. (43)
Blumer et al. (44)
Medically intractable epilepsy
Hospital sample, PWE
Hospital sample, PWE Community study PWE
Hospital sample, PWE
PWE >16 years hospl community sample
Medically intractable epilepsy
Hospital sample, PWE Nigeria
Hospital sample, PWE
Medically intractable CPS
Hospital sample, PWE
Medically intractable epilepsy
Community sample All PWE
Frequent seizures (>]/month)
62 26 47
300 (231 TLE)
696 350 168
Semi-structured interview (PR)
HDRS (PR) HDRS (PR) BPRS (PR)
TABLE 1. Epidemiologic studies o j depression in people with epilepsy
Hospital sample, TLE 666
Number Measure Findings
111 R (PR)
DSM CIS (PR)
SCID (PR), DSM-111-R
HDRS (PR) NDI (PR)
STAI (SR) SSRQ (SR) WPSI (SR) DSM-III-R (PR)
37.3% psychiatric cases 53%: neurosis
50%: depression (DSM-Ill-R)
Lifetime prevalence of 88.3%: any psychiatric disorder
70%: axis I diagnosis 58.3%: depression 31.7%: anxiety
5%: bipolar disorder
18.3%: axis II diagnosis (PD)
47.3%: psychiatric case 29.3%: axis I diagnosis 10.7%: anxiety
3%: mood disorder 4.3%: SLPE
18%: axis I1 diagnosis
Perceived seizure severity, predicted anxiety
52%: psychiatric disorder
57%: interictai dysphoric disorder 67%: interictal dysphoric disorder
TL, temporal lobe; PD, personality disorder; TLE, temporal lobe epilepsy; PWE, people with epilepsy; SLPE, schizophrenia-like psychosis of epilepsy; CNS, central nervous system; Hosp, hospital; MSE, mental state examination; SLPE, chronic psychosis; CPS, complex partial seizure; FLE, frontal lobe epilepsy; PR, physician rated; SR, self-rated; HDRS, Hamilton Depression Rating Scale; PSE, present state examination; BPRS, Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale; SPI, Standardised Psychiatric Interview; CIS, Clinical Interview Schedule; DSM IIIR, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, Edition 111, revised; BDI, Beck Depression Inventory; ZDI, Zung Depression Inventory; SCID, Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-111-R NDI, Newcastle Depression Inventory; LPD, Levine-Pilowsky Depression Questionnaire; STAI, Spielberger State- Trait Anxiety Inventory; SSRQ, Social Readjustment Rating Questionnaire; WPSI, Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory.
Community sample PWE 696 [as in Jacoby et al. (41)]
Medically intractable 60 epilepsy
Medically intractable TLE 44
Medically intractable FLE
review (PR) 7% aggressive, 6% obsessive)
and case no
te 44%: ab
87%: any psychiatric disorder
30%: neurosis (17% depressed, 7% anxious.
22% past psychiatric history (60% depression,
75% depressed mood, 50% anxiety)
54.7% depressed (65% CPS; 42% other seizures) 55%: depression
4 times more PWE had been hospitalized than control
g p with similar socioeconomic and disability levels 26.7%: subjectively depressed
31.1%: objectively depressed
22.2%: subjectively anxious
11.1%: objectively anxious
47.7%: psychiatric cases
21.6%: depressive neurosis
14.8%: anxiety neurosis
47.7%: psychiatric cases
40.3%: psychiatric cases (9.7% anxiety neurosis,
2%: history o
19.4% depressive neurosis)
65.4%: psychiatric cases (26.9% anxiety neurosis,
26.9% depressive neurosis)
f depression 38%: currently depressed
TABLE 2. Etiology
Age at onset of epilepsy
Duration of epilepsy
Number of different seizure types
Localization of focus (LRE vs. PGE; TLE vs. extra-TLE) Lateralization of focus
Seizure control. “forced normalization” Secondary generalization of seizure
Type of AED
Number of AED
Serum level of AED
Secondary effects of AED, e.g., hormonal, serum folate
Effect of epilepsy surgery
Locus of control
Fear of seizures Attributional style Adjustment to epilepsy Parental overprotection Social support Socioeconomic status
PWE, people with epilepsy; HI, head injury; MS, multiple sclerosis; CVA, cerebrovascular accident; SOL, space-occupying lesion; LRE, localization-relatedepilepsy; PGE, primary generalized epilepsy; TLE, temporal lobe epilepsy; AED, antiepileptic drug.
Thompson and Oxley (61) noted that the mean IQ of 92 patients with medically intractable seizures being ad- mitted to a specialist hospital was 83.6. However in the majority of cases this had not been detected at school, which may have contributed to the conduct and emo- tional disturbances observed in these patients.
Lund (62) assessed 302 patients with learning disabil- ity and found that twice the percentage of patients with concomitant epilepsy had a psychiatric disorder (includ- ing behavioral problems and autism) compared with pa- tients without epilepsy. Psychiatric disorder was more common in those who had experienced seizures in the preceding year (52% compared with 36% with a history
of epilepsy) and was inversely proportional to IQ. Stef- fenberg et al. (63) assessed 98 children and adolescents with learning disability and epilepsy and found a psychi- atric disorder (mainly autistic disorder and an autistic- like condition) in over 90% of the patients in whom a psychiatric condition could be categorized. Surprisingly, the two other major studies of patients with learning disability failed to find an increased rate of psychiatric illness in those with epilepsy (64,65). This may reflect the difficulty in diagnosing psychiatric co-morbidity in
A wide variety of metabolic and hormonal changes are reported during ictal activity (66). Enhanced turnover of norepinephrine has been reported in chemically induced seizures, and a wide range of changes in tryptophan and 5-hydroxy indoleacetic acid (5-HIAA) have been docu- mented during both electrically and chemically induced seizures. Norepinephrine, tryptophan, and 5-HIAA have all been implicated in theories regarding the develop- ment of depression. Endocrine changes, such as in- creases in prolactin and vasopressin, are seen after spon- taneous generalized seizures and after both unmodified and modified ECT, suggesting that they are not a con- sequence of the peripheral events of a generalized sei- zure but arise from the electrical seizure activity. In con- trast, increases in plasma growth hormone, adrenocorti- cotropic hormone (ACTH), and cortisol are less after modified ECT compared with unmodified ECT. After
generalized seizures, marked activation of the autonomic nervous system has.been reported, with increases in epi- nephrine and norepinephrine. After prolonged seizures, blood glucose increases, which may promote insulin re- lease, resulting in secondary hypoglycemia (66).
The above changes are a reflection of enhanced neu- ronal and sympathetic activity. Concomitant behavioral changes are believed to result from enhanced excitation and synchronicity in some excitatory systems and from enhanced inhibition affecting other pathways or struc- tures. However, more refined in vivo measurements of neurochemical changes will be required to fully correlate them with behavioral changes (66).
Age of onsetJdurationof epilepsy
Although some studies have found an association be- tween late-onset epilepsy and depression (67), most have found no relationship with either age of onset (29- 31,34,35,39,46,47,51,59) or duration of epilepsy (29,30, 37,39,5139).
Many studies have found depression to be more com- mon in patients with CPS (27,30,31,36,37.54,69). Oth- ers, however, demonstrated that the number of seizure types was correlated with greater risk for psychiatric dis- order (50,70).
Neurologic (e.g., HI, MS, CVA, SOL)
Genetic/environmental factors Endocrine/metabolic factors Epilepsy factors
n people with
trs from profound disability, a problem encountered in a
DEPRESSION IN EPILEPSY
third of the patients in the study of Steffenberg et al. (63).
lly if suff
Several studies have found depression to be more common in patients with TLE (27,32,36,58,71-74). Oth- ers, however have not confirmed the excess psychiatric morbidity in these patients with TLE (29,75,76). Edeh and Toone (33) did not find higher psychiatric morbidity
S26 zyxwM. Vz. LAMvByERT ANuDxM. M. RwOtBERTsSONvzruyqtxpsworqnv
in patients with TLE compared with non-temporal lobe focal epilepsy, but found that focal epilepsy, regardless of site of focus, had more interictal psychopathology than PGE. A study by Hermann et al. (77) found in- creased perseverative responding on the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test and dysphoric mood state in patients with left TLE, suggesting that frontal lobe dysfunction may be an additional factor in the genesis of depression in pa- tients with TLE. Bromfield et al. (78) confirmed this hypothesis by reporting a bilateral reduction in inferior frontal lobe glucose metabolism, in depressed patients with CPS.
suggest that a left-sided origin predisposes for depression (92). A theory has been proposed that the nondominant hemisphere subserves negative feelings, whereas the dominant subserves positive emotional states (93,86). It has been hypothesized that the “release” of the contra- lateral hemisphere after ipsilateral seizure inactivation results in the affective changes (26). Mendez et al. (31) suggested several explanations: (a) the depression is sec- ondary to a focal lesion in the left hemisphere; (b) the depression is caused by continuous subclinical electro- physiologic alterations affecting limbic areas; and (c) depression reflects the interictal perifocal area of “sur- round inhibition” and ipsilateral hypometabolism, ob- served with positron emission tomography (PET) studies (35,38,96-98). Schmitz et al. (99) however, noted that patients with left-sided epilepsy and higher scores on the BDI were found to have more contralateral temporal and bilateral frontal hypoperfusion (measured with SPECT). The authors observed that the hypoperfusion may repre- sent the widespread perfusion changes involving the lim- bic frontal regions seen in people with TLE, which may be related to functional deafferentation, interictal inhibi- tory activity, or postictal depletion of substrates (78,99).
Stevens (76) has criticized studies implicating TLE/
CPS, suggesting the reason for the excess of TLE in
PWE suffering from psychiatric disorders, merely repre-
sents the fact that TLE is the most common type of
epilepsy in adults. Furthermore, other studies have found
no association with seizure type (29,46,79,80) or focus
(54). Manchanda et al. (81) assessed 30 patients with
TLE, 25 with non-temporal lobe focal epilepsy, and 19
with multifocal onset/generalized epilepsy, referred to a
teaching hospital epilepsy investigation unit. Over half
had a DSM-111-R psychiatric disorder, but no significant differencesinpsychiatricmorbiditywereobservedwTheinconsistencviesinfindinugsmayinptartbeesx-r among the different foci. Only 4.25% of the entire group plained by the difficulty in reliably lateralizing the sei-
Lateralization of seizure focus
were diagnosed as having a “mood” disorder (6% with zure focus using scalp EEG electrodes (100).However, TLE, 4% with non-temporal focal epilepsy, and none another explanation for the preponderance of left-sided
with generalized epilepsy).
ci in patients with
rized from the findings of Bear and Fedio (101), who noted that patients with right sided-foci tended to deny or minimize their negative behavior, whereas those with a left-sided focus tended to be more self-critical. Thus, patients with left-sided ictal onset would be more likely to rate themselves as more depressed with self-report measures. To produce more objective ratings, it is sug-
Flor-Henry (82) was the first to suggest a relationship
between laterality of seizure focus and psychosis. He
postulated that depression was associated with nondomi-
nant (right) temporal lobe lesions. However, this conclu-
sion was based on the evaluation of nine patients, of
whom four had a right-sided, two a left-sided, and three gested that physician-rated scales should be used in com- a bilateral focus. Since then, many studies have ad- bination with self-report measures.
dressed the issue of laterality.
Some studies have found that right-sided foci are as- Seizure frequencylseverity and control: the role of
sociated with depression (31;
and several have found that lateralization was not a sig- Several studies have reported a decrease in seizure
nificant etiologic factor (37,59,80,84,85). Most studies, however, have found that although psychiatric disorder in general, especially hypomania (26,86), tends to be associated with right-sided foci, depression appears to be more common in those with left-sided foci (31,35,47,51- 54,78,87-91). Victoroff et al. (38) found that left-sided ictal onset and hypometabolism were associated with a history of and current depression in patients with CPS. However, patients with right-sided hypometabolism also had a history of major depression, suggesting that left- sided ictal onset and degree of hypometabolism were independent risk factors for development of depression.
In summary, although there are studies associating de- pression with either left- or right-sided foci, the majority
frequency before the onset of the depressive illness (29, 72,82,102). Mendez et al. (47) found that patients with epilepsy and depression had significantly fewer general- ized seizures than those without depression. These au- thors postulated that nonreactive depression may occur when AED therapy prevents generalization from an epi- leptic focus. Others, however, have not found an associa- tion (31,3734) and still others have even documented an association with an increase in seizure frequency (70,103). Recent quality of life studies have found fre- quent seizures to be associated with increased anxiety, depression, and stigma (41,104), as is perceived seizure severity (42). Trostle et al. (49) reported fewer psycho- social problems (assessed using the Washington Psycho-
Epilepsia, Vol. 40, Suppl. 10, 1999
n be the
social Seizure Inventory, WPSI) in patients who were not receiving AEDs and had been seizure-free during the preceding year. Those who were seizure-free on AEDs had intermediate scores. Patients who continued to ex- perience seizures despite AEDs had the most severe psy-
chosocial problems. Severity of seizures was associated with the seventy of self-reported psychosocial problems.
Polypharmacy has been shown to be associated with
depression in patients with epilepsy (47,50), and Shor-
von and Reynolds (105) reported an improvement in alertness,concentration,drive,mood,andsociabilityaf-andcaseseries(131)havezfoundLTGytobeefficacxiousw ter reduction of polytherapy to monotherapy. in bipolar affective disorder.
Certain AEDs have been found to be psychotropic, Topiramate has been shown to be an effective second- and others are associated with behavioral changes and line AED, and depression appears to occur no more com-
depression. Phenobarbital (PB) has been associated with monly than with placebo
depression in adults (55,106). Brent et al. (107) found a found to have minimal side effects, not significantly dif-
higher prevalence of both depression (40% vs. 4%) and suicidal ideation (47% vs. 4%) in adolescents and chil- dren taking PB compared with carbamazepine (CBZ). Dodrill (108) reviewed 90 studies in which the behav- ioral effects of phenytoin (PHT), barbiturates, CBZ, or valproic acid (VPA) were assessed in patients with epi- lepsy and normal volunteers. Barbiturates were most clearly associated with negative behavioral changes, in-
cluding depression. In more than half the studies, posi- tive behavioral changes were associated with CBZ (decreased anxiety and depression) and VPA (improved mood and increased happiness). Phenytoin produced positive and negative effects in similar numbers of re- ports. A recent double-blind prospective study compared the efficacy and toxicity of PHT, primidone (PRM), PB, and CBZ. At 1 year, behavioral toxicity scores were highest for those on PHT and lowest for CBZ (109). Dalby (110) reported a psychotropic effect in approxi- mately half the patients treated with CBZ, which has
also been shown to be associated with less depression than PRM (73) and PHT (111). CBZ is also efficacious as an antidepressant in patients without epilepsy and is prophylactic in the control of manic-depressive illness (112-114), as is VPA (112,114-116).
Fewer studies have been performed with the newer anticonvulsants. Vigabatrin (VGB) is an irreversible in- hibitor of y-aminobutyric acid (GABA)-transaminase and thus increases levels of the inhibitory neurotransmit- ter GABA. This drug appears to be particularly associ- ated with depression, developing in up to 10% of patients (117). The depression typically occurs within a few weeks after the drug is introduced or after dose incre- ments. A past history of psychiatric disturbance has been found to be a major risk factor (1IS).
Efficacy data (1 19) have shown lamotrigine (LTG) to
ferent from placebo (133) and also has the advantage of not inducing liver enzymes (132). Case reports also sug- gest it may be efficacious in bipolar disorder (134,135). The most recent AED to be licensed as adjunctive therapy in the United Kingdom is tiagabine (TGB), which acts by blocking the uptake of GABA into neurons and glia. Concern has been expressed, however, that TGB may be associated with the development of depres- sion because, like VGB, it increases the cerebral level of GABA. Intravenous GABA can produce dysphoria and anxiety in both normal volunteers and patients with bi- polar affective disorder (136). Early reports have docu- mented asthenia, nervousness, and depression to be ad- verse events (137-1 39), although a recent monotherapy study reported adverse mood changes only with rapidly
titrated high-dose TGB (140). It is therefore too soon to make recommendations about TGB, but at present cau- tion is advised in prescribing it for patients with a history of psychiatric disorder.
Caution must be exercised in withdrawing AEDs, es- pecially benzodiazepines and barbiturates, because both depression and anxiety have been reported after discon- tinuation of anticonvulsants (141,142).
For further discussion of depression and AEDs, see Schmitz, this issue.
Metabolic effects of AEDs
be at least as effective in producing seizure freedom as CBZ, while being better tolerated (fewer adverse effects and withdrawals from the study). Several studies have shown improvements in well-being with LTG add-on therapy (120-124). Lamotrigine has also been found to
produce increased happiness and mastery (perceived in-
ternal control) than placebo, which was not dependent on change in seizure frequency or severity (125). Mono- therapy studies have shown that LTG produced improve- ments in all the Side Effect and Life Satisfaction
(SEALS) Inventory scores (cognition, dysphoria, temper, tiredness, and worry) compared with CBZ (126,127) and improvement in the SEALS score for dysphoria com- pared with PHT (126,128). Recent case reports (129,130)
Pratt et al. (143) reported that PB and PHT reduced plasma free tryptophan, whereas CBZ increased levels compared with normal volunteers and untreated patients with epilepsy. Plasma free tryptophan influences seroto- nin turnover. Therefore, the authors postulated that this may be the mechanism that produces the psychotropic effect of CBZ and the depressant effects of PB and PHT.
40, Suppl. 1
pentin has b
c disorders o
qy AED therapy causes a decrease in serum, red blood due to a seizure-suppressing inhibitory mechanism.
M. M. R
ing LTG has found no reduction in folate (149). Folate Many investigators have found the
side of temp
oral deficiency has been associated with psychiatric morbid- lobe surgery to be predictive of postoperative depression.
ity (predominantly depression) in patients both with (144,145,147) and without epilepsy (150-152). Vitamin B,, deficiency has also been documented in patients with epilepsy, especially those with psychiatric disturbance. It is believed to be secondary to the antifolate action of the AEDs (147) and may be exacerbated by the administra- tion of oral folic acid supplements (153). Folates appear to have a major role in methylation in the nervous system (154). Methylfolate donates its methyl group to homo- cysteine to form methionine (which is catalyzed by B,,), which then passes the methyl group to S-adenosyl- methionine (SAMe). SAMe is the sole methyl donor in the brain in many methylation reactions involving neu- rotransmitters and monoamines, which are believed to be implicated in the etiology of affective disorder. SAMe has been found to have antidepressant properties and raises 5-HIAA and HVA (by products of monoamine metabolism) in the CSF. There has been little published research on the effect of administering folate supple-
ments to patients with epilepsy. This is partly because of
concerns about the proconvulsant properties of folic acid
(153,155). However, there have been reports of an im-
provement in drive, speed of cerebration, alertness, con-
centration, and well-being in patients with documented
folate deficiency after oral folic acid supplements (es- bectomy, especially if there is only partial improvement pecially if supplemented with vitamin B,,), although in in their seizures (9,59,159,161,162). Despite this, little half of these patients the seizure control deteriorated research has examined this surprising and important as-
DEPRESSION AFTER EPILEPSY SURGERY
There have been several studies, many several decades old, assessing postoperative depression. These are sum- marized below.
Most authors have found that complete freedom from seizures is necessary for a postoperative reduction in depression (44,59,156-161). Blumer et al. (44) have sug-
Epilepsia, Vol. 40, Suppl. 10, 1999
Therefore, the postoperative lessening of excitatory ac- tivity and relative predominance of inhibition may pre- dispose to the emergence of dysphoric, affective, and psychotic disorders. If there is a recurrence of seizures, renewed seizure-suppressing activity may also produce psychiatric morbidity. Patients not rendered seizure-free (even with >75% improvement of seizures) do not ap- pear to have any change in levels of depression, behav- ioral, or emotional adjustment (9,59,157,160,162,163). Patients only experiencing SPS postoperatively also
cell, and CSF folate levels in 11-15% of patients with
epilepsy compared with normal controls (144,145), al-
though earlier studies assessing outpatients taking barbi-
turates and/or phenytoin documented low folate in half to
three-quarters of patients (146,147). Reynolds et al.
(147) also reported megaloblastic hemopoiesis in 38% of
the patients whose sternal marrow was examined, which
reversed with oral folic acid therapy. Although reduced
folate has been documented with most AEDs, it is more
marked in patients receiving polytherapy (144,145,147) anditappearstobemorecommonwiththeliveren-continuetoexperiencedepression(16z4),perhapsybe-x zyme-inducing AEDs (145). Most studies assessing VPA cause the continued premonitory symptoms may act as a
have found little effect unless the patient was also taking reminder of their seizures and cause alarm that the aura enzyme inducers (145,148), and the single study assess- may herald a generalized seizure.
However, the various studies have produced contradic- tory findings. Fenwick et al. (165) assessed 96 patients after temporal lobectomy. A quarter had postoperative depressive symptoms, of which 72% had undergone a right-sided and 28% a left-sided operation. Other authors have also reported more mood changes after right-sided surgery (166).
Depression has been reported occurring de novo after temporal lobectomy (28,44,167-169) and amygdalohip- pocampectomy (166). Parashos et al. (170) reported the development of bipolar affective disorder and depres- sioddysthymia after anterior temporal lobectomy. Post- operative MRI scans revealed ipsilateral degeneration of the thalamus and putamen in both patients.
Postoperative depression tends to be more common in the first 2 months after surgery (44,17 1,172) and is often transient (171). Ring et al. (43) observed that at 6 weeks after surgery 27% had developed de novo symptoms of anxiety and 23% of depression, and 45% of patients had increased emotional lability. At 3 months after surgery, emotional lability and anxiety symptoms had diminished but depression tended to persist.
Many studies have shown a deterioration in the psy- chivatric and soucial status oftpatientssafter temrporal lo-
t of epileps
y surgery. E
from seizures can be associated with depression and be- havioral problems (159,163,170). Ferguson and Rayport (173) discussed this in 1965, suggesting that it was the abrupt (surgical) removal of a psychiatrically significant experience, the seizure, rather than the removal of tem- poral lobe tissue that was of major psychological impor- tance. They postulated that the postoperative seizure-free state permits assessment of the extent to which the sei- zure disorder has been incorporated into the adaptive
patterns of the patient. They proposed that epilepsy may afford some patients psychological benefits. The illness may shield them from any hostile feelings friends and relatives may have toward the patient. In the series re- portedbyBladin(163),6%ofpatientsfoundadjustingto life without seizures so difficult that the situation re- sulted in divorce. The patient may use epilepsy as an “excuse”for failures in personal, social, and occupational areas. It may even allow inappropriate behavior to be
such as job loss, lack of friends, or relationship difficul- ties, to their epilepsy. This pessimistic attributional style has been associated with the development of depression (180).
ever, have not found any change (improvement epilepsy unit for assessment. Over half of the group re- or deterioration) in psychiatric status postoperatively, re- ported psychosocial problems in several areas. Moderate
gardless of outcome with respect to seizure control (58). to severe employment difficulties were reported in 71
Taylor (28) and Rausch (176) have determined pre- and the majority of those who had been employed had dictors of a postoperative improvement in psychosocial performed only unskilled work. Seizure control did not
1. Excellent seizure control.
2. No or mild preoperative psychopathology.
3. Good family support.
4. Good preoperative relationships at work and with
5. Age at surgery <30 years.
6. Good schooling and higher preoperative IQ.
Epilepsy is associated with repeated but unpredictable
episodes of loss of consciousness or alteration in behav-
ior, often resulting in embarrassment and loss of dignity
(54). This unpredictability and uncontrollability has been
compared with Seligman’s concept of “learned helpless-
ness,” which occurs when patients are exposed to ad-
verse experizences on a ranydom basis (17×7-179). Her-wWhitmanv(56)showedthautincreasedstressfullifeevents, mann (178) proposed that this may predispose to depres- poor adjustment to seizures, and financial stress were sion, and this has been developed into the concept of predictive of increased depression. However, such psy- locw of control. Preoperative depression has been cor- chosocial factors may have been the consequence of de-
events not being attributable to the patient’s own efforts Roth et al. (103) assessed the physical exercise pat-
an external locu
s of control (a
ather than the
cause of it.
but rather to the effects of fate) (59). More recently, the concept of attributional style has been viewed as a marker of learned helplessness. A pessimistic attribu- tional style is characterized by the attribution of causality for positive events to “external, unstable and specific causes” and negative or adverse events to “internal, stable and global causes,” an example of which is epi- lepsy. Patients with epilepsy and a pessimistic attribu- tional style may therefore attribute global difficulties,
terns along with depression levels (measured using the BDI) in 133 outpatients attending an epilepsy center. Only 30% of the group were classified as “active” (par- ticipating in at least 20 min of exercise at a minimum of three times a week), and half the patients reported no exercise at all. Thirty-two percent of active patients were depressed compared with 59% of the nonactive patients. This finding was independent of variables such as age, gender, seizure frequency, or stressful life experiences.
Many studies have reported a deterioration in quality of life in patients with epilepsy (181,182), which may adversely affect mood ( 1 83). Rodin et al. ( I 84) reported that more than half of their sample of patients had a psychological or social problem with behavioral mani- festations. Similar findings were reported by Dodrill et al. (185), who assessed 315 patients with epilepsy from a wide range of social and educational backgrounds, suf- fering from different seizure types with varying age of onset, using the WPSI. They found emotional, interper- sonal, vocational, and financial concerns in over half the patients. Thompson and Oxley (61) assessed socioeco-
accepted. After the operation, the family may expect a
radical change in personality and may become critical of
the patient’s behavior and weaknesses. This may cause
the patient to become depressed and even to wish that
surgery had never been performed. Somatization and the
development of non-epileptic attack disorder (NEAD)
may occur. Preoperative counseling and postoperative rehabilitationmayhelppatientsandtheirfamiliesadjustnomicdifficultiesin92patientswithsevere,medicazllyy to life without seizures (174,175). Some authors, how- intractable epilepsy who were admitted to a specialist
necessarily correlate with ability to find work because
other factors, such as social skills, emotional stability,
poor motivation, low self-esteem, and feelings of depen-
dency and helplessness, also contributed. In general, dis- satisfaction was related to the undemanding nature of the work, although a perceived need to “prove themselves” to colleagues and employers was also reported. The au- thors stressed that employment did not merely provide an income but also provided a daily occupation, which in turn would enhance self-esteem. Employment rehabilita- tion needs to focus on providing skills to cope with fear of seizures and job stress along with job finding and interview techniques. Three-quarters of the sample were dissatisfied with their social life, 68% had no personal friends, and 34% had never formed a “true friendship.” Only 16% were in a steady relationship, despite the fact that 71% were over the age of 20 years. Hermann and
Epilepsia, Vol. 4
S30 zyxMw. Vz. LAMByERT AvNDxM. M.uROwBERTSONtzvsyurxtqswrpqvo
Goffman (194) defined stigma as any “attribute that is deeply discrediting” and believed that whether an indi- vidual was stigmatized by a trait depended on the atti- tudes of those perceiving the trait. For an attribute to be perceived as stigmatizing, the individual should have limited the disclosure of the attribute to few others and the individual should perceive that, if that attribute were more widely known, significant redefinition of self, ac- companied by various restrictions and regulation of con- duct, would follow (191,194). The stigmatizing nature of epilepsy has caused the psychosocial problems to out- weigh the clinical problems of seizure control. This is demonstrated by the fact that although only around 20% of patients with epilepsy develop chronic, intractable epi- lepsy, the majority continue to live with the label “epi- leptic” (195). Much of the literature assessing stigma in people with epilepsy was written in the 196Os, but un- fortunately stigma still affects these patients to the pre- sent day. Epilepsy has long been associated with disrepu- tability, satanic possession, and evil ( 1 96), violence (197-199). Myths, misconceptions, prejudice, and super- stitions are still associated with epilepsy (61). In some states in America, people with epilepsy were not eligible for federal civil service positions until 1959 and prohi- bitions against marriage were in place until 1965 (200). It remains difficult for people with a history of seizures to obtain life, holiday, and car insurance (201). A recent
personal (MVL) visit to China in 1998 revealed that
“epileptics” were banned from using a chair lift, as were
people with psychiatric conditions. Schneider and Con-
rad (191) interviewed 80 people with epilepsy about their
experiences of “coming out of the closet” with respect to
admitting the details of their “medical condition” to oth-
ers. Several patients reported that the lay public did not
understand what epilepsy was, in that many people still
regarded epilepsy to incorporate elements of madness
and evil. Some patients “test” society’s reaction to their zy epilepsy by selectively informing close associates of
their condition. Their confidants’ reactions tend to influ- ence future disclosure. Many patients were willing to share information about their epilepsy with close friends
The inactive patients were more likely to be afraid of
looking stupid or unattractive during exercise and were
more afraid that a seizure would be precipitated by ex-
ercise (or had previously experienced a seizure during
exercise) than the active group. Fifteen percent of the
inactive group had been advised to avoid most types of
exercise by their physician. From this study, it is not
possible to deztermine whyether exercixse reduces dwepres- a respvonse to contuinued seizurestrather than the cause of sion or whether depressed individuals exercise less. them. Families need to be encouraged to learn appropri- However, research has demonstrated that exercise re- ate reactions to seizures and ways to promoting indepen- duces depression in patients both without (186-1 88) and dent living skills, to prevent their lives revolving around
was responsible for the lower rates of depression in the active group.
Children with epilepsy
A child with epilepsy needs to find ways of adapting to the diagnosis while developing strategies for dealing with self-identity, family overprotection/guilt, and the environment. Some children may use their seizures as a way of controlling the family environment and this, in turn, may result in the later development of nonepileptic seizures.
Parental expectations of their child with epilepsy, along with family and social rejection, have been found to have deleterious effects on the psychological devel- opment of the child (190). Feelings of shame, expressed as secrecy and fear of exposure, have been reported to be learned from parents. The more a parent conveys a defi- nition of epilepsy as something “bad,” the more likely the child will see it as something to be concealed. Parents who see their child’s epilepsy as “just like any other medical condition” will encourage their children to have a more neutral view, with a more open “information control strategy,” and will limit the use of epilepsy as a “crutch” or “excuse” (191). Unfortunately, parents who do treat their child with epilepsy normally, allowing them to lead an active life, may feel guilty if their child is injured during a seizure while taking part in typical childhood pursuits, such as climbing trees or riding a bicycle. Overprotective parents, on the other hand, may produce reactions of rebellion or passivity from their child. Physicians and friends also have been reported to encourage concealment as a strategy for dealing with epilepsy (191). Long and Moore (192) compared 19 chil- dren with epilepsy with their closest-in-age sibling. They found that parents expected their child with epilepsy to have more emotional problems and to be more unpre- dictable and highly strung. The parents were more domi- nant, restrictive, and strict with their child with epilepsy, 32% believed the child should be supervised at all times, 28% prohibited swimming, 21% cycling, and 16% team games. Children with epilepsy were found to have lower self-esteem than their siblings, were more socially iso- lated, and underachieved at school, especially with re-
Epilepsia, Vol. 40, Suppl. 10, 1999
(1 89). Ther
efore, it is l
ikely that ex
ercise the fa
spect to reading. These findings appear to affect both psychosocial development and seizure control. Hauck (193) reported that 61% of children of “autocratic” par- ents continued to have seizures despite 3 years of ad- equate AEDs, whereas 61% of children of “nonauto- cratic” parents were seizure-free. However, it is possible that the overprotectiveness of the autocratic parents was
r with epileps
DEPRESSION IN EPILEPSY S31 zy
but not with prospecztive emplyoyers or thxose involvewd in Fear ovf seizuresutsrqp the issuing of drivers’ licenses. Scambler and Hopkins Mittan (206,207) first reported that patients with epi-
(202) reported that over two-thirds of patients did not lepsy tend to express fears about dying or severely in-
inform their partners about their seizures until after the juring themselves during seizures, and concerns about
marriage, and only
provision of epilepsy support groups has been an impor- atric illness and cognitive decline. Although some of
tant step in providing support for patients with epilepsy and comparing experiences of the effects of “coming out of the closet”. Ryan et al. (203) assessed 445 people with epilepsy from a variety of socioeconomic levels and em- ployment histories and with a wide range of seizure vari- ables. They found that stigma was not universally per- ceived and was not related to frequency and severity of seizures. Eighty-one percent felt that they had been treated fairly by employers and 70% felt neither unrea- sonably limited nor treated differently because of sei- zures. However, 22% reported that they had been dis-
missed from at least one of their previous four jobs for an epilepsy-relatedreason. Perceived stigma was dependent on perceived employment discrimination, perceived sei- zure-imposed limitations, years of education and, to a minimal extent, on the age and sex of the individual. Similarly, Jacoby et al. (195) found that only 14% of 607 patients in remission experienced stigma. However, pa- tients who scored positively for stigma also had lower scores for self-esteem and mastery and had been seizure- free for less time. Those who scored negatively for stigma tended to be over SO years of age. Although only
2% recalled an occasion in which they had been treated unfairly at work and only 3% believed that their epilepsy was the reason for their current lack of employment, 32% believed that their epilepsy had made it more difficult to obtain a job (195).
Recently, “felt” stigma has been differentiated from “enacted” stigma (195,204,205). Enacted stigma refers to episodes of discrimination, whereas felt stigma refers to the shame associated with being “epileptic” and the fear of enacted stigma. Felt stigma was much more prevalent than enacted stigma and was the product of stigma coaching, usually by parents. It preceded rather than re- sulted from periods of enacted stigma and was the major source of unease, self-doubt, and disruption (205). Scam- bler and Hopkins (205) also reported that patients be- lieved that when they were told their diagnosis, they
An essential prerequisite for treatment of depression in people with epilepsy is making the correct diagnosis. Studies have found that hospital medical and nursing staff fail to detect affective disorder in 3672% of cases
ed their e
The the lon
these fears may be realistic, many are the consequence of lack of knowledge and misperceptions of the actual risks associated with epilepsy. Patients who exhibit a high number of fears and concerns tend to have more emo- tional and behavioral difficulties, including lack of con- fidence, depression, and anxiety. Goldstein et al. (208) assessed fear of seizures in 96 patients with various de- grees of seizure control. They found that concern about emotional functioning, followed by concerns about avoiding seizure-inducing stimuli, were the most fre- quently endorsed items. They also found that these concerns were related to behavioral and emotional ad-
justment regardless of demographic and neuroseizure variables. These authors conclude that modifying mal- adaptive cognitions and beliefs may help correct misper- ceptions and irrational fears and, in so doing, improve behavioral and emotional adjustment. They advocate the use of cognitive-behavioral therapy for this purpose. Others, however, have found no relationship between depression and psychosocial factors such as socioeco- nomic status (37), education ( 3 7 5 l ) , and employment status (51).
In summary, most authors have found no correlation between depression and epilepsy variables such as age of onset, the presence of an intracranial lesion or seizure frequency (31). However, CPSs and TLE, especially of left-sided origin in men, have been associated with de- pression (56) and severity of depression has been found to correlate with duration of epilepsy (54). Although psy- chosocial factors may play a part, depression appears to occur more in patients with epilepsy than in patients with other neurologic disorders (31,46,47) or chronic medical conditions (74), suggesting that an organic mood disor- der rather than a reaction to a chronic disability is the major etiologic factor.
DIAGNOSIS OF INTERICTAL DEPRESSION
perceived stigma and affective disorder, especially per- cases (210). One reason for this may be making the as-
became transformed from “normal” people to “epilep-
tics” and they believed that they had a stigmatizing con-
dition, despite the fact that few could recall any inci- dencesofactualstigmaordiscriminationagainstthem.(209),andthatgeneralpractitionerscozrrectlydiagnyosex Arnston (204) reported a positive relationship between depression at the first consultation only in 50% of the
ceived helplessness, depression, anxiety, and somatic sumption
symptoms, and a negative relationship with self-esteem “You’d be depressed too, if you had. .
and life satisfaction. Similarly, Jacoby (195) reported an the depressive disorder is not diagnosed, the patient will association between stigma and the subjects’ affective continue to suffer from two disabilities, at least one of
e fully tre
rmal reac utsrtion to illnqp
n is a no
Epilepsra, Vol. 4
. .” Howeve
0, Suppl. 1
S32 zyxwM. V. LAMBEvRT AND Mu. M. ROBERtTSONszryqxpwov
Betts (212) has differentiated between a depressive reaction (or reactive depression) and a depressive illness (or endogenous depression). Depressive feelings usually respond to circumstance and tend to be understandable as a reaction to an event. Betts describes a “grief reaction” that may affect the patient and family when the diagnosis of epilepsy is given. First, there may be a period of denial followed by struggle (during which guilt and anger may be experienced) and then depressive feelings as they come to terms with the diagnosis. This depressive reac- tion should be regarded as normal. Patients and their family should be encouraged to work through it until acceptance and resignation occur (212).
Depressive illness can be diagnosed using the fnter- national Classification of Disease criteria (ICD10). De- pressed mood, reduced energy, and loss of interest and enjoyment are the main symptoms, two of which should be present for at least 2 weeks, for a diagnosis of mild or moderate depression, and all three for severe depression. In addition, two of the following symptoms should be present for mild, three for moderate, and four for severe depression: reduced concentration and attention, reduced self-esteedself-confidence, ideas of guilt and unworthi- ness, pessimistic views of the future, ideas or acts of self-harm or suicide, disturbed sleep, and diminished ap- petite (213). One can also diagnose depression according to DSM-IV criteria (214), which also have strict stipu- lations.
dysthymic, with irritability and humourlessness. Betts (212) also reports that depression in patients with epi- lepsy tends to be endogenous with sudden onset, fluctu- ating markedly until it suddenly ends.
Robertson et al. (54) assessed 66 patients with epi- lepsy referred to a neuropsychiatric department at a ter- tiary refemal center who fulfilled the Research Diagnos- tic Criteria (RDC) for major depressive disorder (215). The Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) (216), the BDI (217), and the Levine-Pilowsky Depression Questionnaire (LPD) (218) showed them to be “moder- ately depressed.” The majority (60%)were classified as having an endogenous depression using the Newcastle Diagnostic Scale (NDI) (219) and the LPD. High hostil- ity scores were obtained especially for the intropunitive measures of self-criticism and guilt.
Blumer et al. (220) noted that some patients with epi- lepsy experienced episodic depressive episodes lasting up to 12 h, occurring on average five times a month, along with periods of euphoria lasting up to 4 h, on average three times a month. They further investigated these symptoms in 75 patients with epilepsy undergoing neurodiagnostic monitoring (221) and found 44% to have an interictal dysphoric disorder. The syndrome comprised eight symptoms, of which most patients ex- perienced five: depressive moods (intense to the point of suicidal despair), accompanied by anergia, pain, insom- nia, anxiety, phobic fears, intermittent paroxysmal irri- tability (to the point of explosive anger or rage), and euphoric moods (consisting of a “sudden, endogenous
The low mood tends to be pervasive and long-lasting.
Classically, patients wake early feeling unrefreshed, with
low mood that may improve as the day progresses (di- sense of blissful euphoria in the absence of elated hy- urnal mood variation). Despite these guidelines, diagno- peractivity”). Blumer stressed that patients with a large sis can be difficult and Betts (212) has also stressed that number of the above symptoms may be at increased risk drug intoxication (especially with PHT), can resemble for sudden unexpected suicide attempts and the develop-
Mendez et al. (31) compared 20 hospitalized de- pressed patients with epilepsy with 20 patients suffering from depression alone. They found that more than half of the depressed patients presented with an agitated, psy- chotic depression with impulsive suicidal behavior. Both groups had a similar number of prior suicide attempts and shared the following characteristics of depression: anhedonia, tearfulness, psychomotor retardation, reduced energy and libido, along with appetite and sleep distur- bances. Patients with epilepsy and depression had sig- nificantly fewer “neurotic” traits such as anxiety, guilt, rumination, hopelessness, low self-esteem, and somati- zation. However, these patients had significantly more “psychotic” symptoms such as paranoia, delusions, and
qrp symptoms, not merely the depressive ones, tend to re-
PHENOMENOLOGY OF INTERICTAL DEPRESSION
major depression, patients with epilepsy tended to be treated medically unless prolonged, and therefore atypi-
hallucinations. Between episodes of
0, Suppl. 10
t of an in
spond rapidly to low-dose antidepressants.
TREATMENT OF INTERICTAL DEPRESSION
Supportive therapy provided by trained therapists, so-
cial workers, or epilepsy nurse specialists should be of-
fered to all newly diagnosed patients and their families
(174). This would provide an opportunity to educate the
patients and their families about epilepsy, to determine
their emotional reactions to the condition, and to correct
false beliefs. Ziegler (222) suggested the approach of
optimistic fatalism, explaining that they have epilepsy,
which may or may not get better, and suggesting that
they focus on “how to make the best of it.” zy
Depressive reactions should be treated with supportive therapy, counseling (174), and rehabilitation (175). Betts (212) has stressed that these reactions should not be
cal, because such episodes may become protracted if treated with antidepressants or tranquilizers. More severe reactions may require specialized psychotherapy, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (223). An intervention pro- cedure to alter attributional style toward optimism has been developed for patients with epilepsy which may ameliorate depression (224). Psychotherapy can also be used to improve coping skills, and this has been shown to improve mild depressive illness and anxiety and to re-
duce seizure frequency (21). Ferguson and Rayport (173) advocate rehabilitation following epilepsy surgery, to en- able the patients to live without the help of an illness that had been both a “weapon and a shield”.
Patient support groups introduce patients to fellow
overcome feelings of hopelessness, rejection and isola- tion. Becd et al. (225) showed in an uncontrolled trial that self-help group intervention can significantly modify depression and dysthymia in outpatients with epilepsy.
Adjustment of AEDs
The seizure and epilepsy syndrome should be reevalu- ated and treated with the most appropriate AED, prefer- ably as monotherapy. Valproate, CBZ, and LTG should be considered as first-line AEDs and, whenever possible, barbiturates, PHT, and VGB should be avoided. How- ever, priority should be given to attaining optimal control because remission of seizures has been found to be ac- companied by an improvement in psychosocial function- ing (226).
Approximately 60-70% of acute major depressive epi- sodes will respond to antidepressant treatment (227), and early treatment intervention has been shown to reduce the duration of the episode by almost 50% (228). How-
ever, antidepressant treatment is often prescribed in sub- therapeutic amounts, Tyrer (229) found that a quarter of patients referred by general practitioners to a psychiatric outpatient clinic were receiving inadequate doses, and this has also been reported in teaching hospitals (230). After complete remission of symptoms, antidepressant therapy should be continued for at least 4 months to reduce the chance of relapse (231).
Choice of antidepressant
In the United Kingdom, there are currently almost 30 drugs licensed for treatment of depression (Table 3). The choice of agent for patients with epilepsy depends on the most prominent symptoms of depression in each patient (e.g., insomnia, anxiety, psychomotor retardation, sexual dysfunction, and suicidal ideation), efficacy, interactions with concomitant medication, side-effect profile, and particularly the epileptogenic potential.
Maprotiline Mianserin Trazodone Viloxazine
(e.g., mature cheese, pate, pickled fish, beer, red wine, yeast extracts) and over-the-counter cold cures containing sympathomimetic amines, can precipitate a hypertensive crisis, the “cheese reaction” (232).
Isocarboxacid Phenelzine Tranylcypromine
Newer antidepressants zyxw Reversible inhibitor of monoamine oxidase A (RIMA):
Moclobeiaide. Safe without dietary restrictions in major studies (233) but patients should avoid eating large quantities
of tyramine-rich foods ( e g , >
50 g of stro
should take the medication after meals Selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs)
Fluvoxamine Fluoxetine Sertraline Paroxetine Citalopram
Serotonin reuptake inhibitor (and serotonin type 2 receptor blocker)
Serotonin norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor
Norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor
Noradrenergic and specific serotonergic antidepressant (NaSSA)
Davis and Glassman (234) reviewed 44 controlled tri- als comparing imipramine, a tricyclic antidepressant (TCA), with placebo, and found that 65% of those on imipramine improved compared with 30% on placebo. It is widely believed that the newer antidepressants do not significantly differ with respect to efficacy compared with the TCAs (235-237), although there is some evi- dence that venlafaxine may have a more rapid onset of action (238).
DEPRESSION zIN EPILEyPSY zxywxvs3wu3 ztyv
TABLE 3. Antidepressants currently available in the United Kingdom
Tricyclics (TCAs): Anticholinergic and antimuscarinic side
effects, such as drowsiness, dry mouth, blurred vision, constipation and urinary retention are common. Hypotension, dizziness, syncope, and confusion common in the elderly
sufferers who can provide emotional support and helpzyxwvu Related antidepressants
se (MAO) inhib
There has only been one double-blind, placebo- controlled study of antidepressants in patients with epi- lepsy (239), which compared amitriptyline with nomi-
itors: Tyramine rich f
Epilepsia, Vol. 4
ng cheese) an
0. Suppl. 10
s34zyxM.wV.LAMBERT ANvD M.M. ROuBERTSONztysxrqwpv
fensine in 42 patients. At 6 weeks all patients had im-
proved, with no significant differences between the
active drugs and placebo. Between weeks 6 and 12, ami- triptylinewascomparedwithnomifensine,withnopla-P450lA2,2D6,and3A4isoenzymes(264),incliniczaly cebo control, and at 12 weeks, nomifensine was found to practice it is unlikely that it would inhibit the metabolism
be superior. of coadministered AEDs (265).
Most of the above reports are single case studies, and
Interactions in clinical practice the greatest risk of toxicity would
In theory, monoamine oxidase (MAO) inhibitors withfluoxetineorfluvoxamineincombinationwithPHT
should not be co-administered with CBZ because this may precipitate a hypertensive crisis (240). However, studies have reported no adverse interactions with phen- elzine, tranylcypromine (241), or moclobemide (242). There has been a case report (243) of the toxic serotonin syndrome (TSS), consisting of uncontrollable shivering, agitation, incoordination, restlessness in feet when sit- ting, involuntary contractions progressing to myoclonic- like leg movements, hyperreflexia, and a frightened hy- perarousal state believed to be secondary to the concomi- tant use of fluoxetine in a patient receiving CBZ for an affective disorder.
The majority of antidepressants are either metabolized by or inhibit, to various degrees, one or more of the cytochrome P450 isoenzymes in the liver, the clinical relevance of which has been reviewed by Nemeroff (244).Itisestimatedthat5-10% ofthewhitepopulation lack the isoenzyme P450 2D6 (slow metabolizers) and are at risk for developing toxic plasma concentrations at normal “therapeutic” doses of drugs metabolized by this liver enzyme, which include several TCAs, fluoxetine, paroxetine, and venlafaxine (244). A simple assay is available, however, to screen for those at risk (245).
Clinically relevant interactions for patients with epi- lepsy that involve the cytochrome P450 system are mainly associated with concomitant use of antidepres- sants with PHT and CBZ (Table 7). The metabolism of PHT is believed to be catalyzed by the P4502C isoen- zymes (244,246). It is estimated that 3-5% of the white population are poor metabolizers of P450 2C19 (244). Imipramine (246), fluoxetine, fluvoxamine, and sertra- line (244) are believed to inhibit these eznzymes. Case reports have demonstrated raised PHT levels with fluox- etine (247-250), and sertraline (251). However, other studies have failed to find raised PHT levels with sertra- line (252) or paroxetine (253). CBZ is metabolized by the P450 3A isoenzymes (244,246), which are believed to be inhibited by fluoxetine, fluvoxamine, sertraline, and nefazodone (244). A normal volunteer study dem- onstrated elevated CBZ levels after concomitant medi- cation with fluoxetine (254), and adverse events have been reported, with raised plasma concentrations of CBZ, with fluoxetine (255,256), fluvoxamine (257,258), sertraline (259), and nefazodone (260). Raised levels have also been reported with viloxazine (261). However, the mechanism for this has not been identified (246).
or CBZ, whereas sertraline, paroxetine, and citalopram have little effect and therefore should not produce clini- cally significant interactions (244,266,267).
The anticonvulsants PB, PRM, PHT, and CBZ are potent liver enzyme inducers (268), which can result in reduced plasma levels and therefore reduced efficacy of antidepressants metabolized by the same isoenzymes. Clinically significant interactions have been reported with TCAs (269) and paroxetine (270).
Safety: adverse effects at therapeutic levels
Sedation. Most of the older antidepressants, espe- cially the TCAs, mianserin, and trazodone (271,272),pro- duce sedative side effects (Table 7). This may be par- ticularly troublesome to patients taking AEDs known to cause sedation, such as barbiturates and benzodiaz- epines, and one report (273) suggests that sedative anti- depressants are more epileptogenic. Sedative antidepres- sants may be given to patients with co-existent anxiety or agitation but they may result in daytime drowsiness and impaired psychomotor function. In patients with sleep disturbance, drugs known to improve sleep architecture, such as moclobemide (274), nefazodone (275), or mirtazapine (276), should be considered. Hindmarch et al. (272) showed that lofepramine, moclobemide, and the SSRIs were associated with equal or even less psycho-
Other studies have failed to find raised CBZ levels with paroxetine (253), sertraline (252), fluoxetine, or fluvox- amine (263). Although mirtazapine is a weak inhibitor of
ng than pla
tamine-blocking properties, especially at low doses mg/day) and therefore is associated with sedation in 19%
4. Factors a
History of previous seizures
Family history of a seizure disorder
Abnormal pre-treatment EEG
Brain damage, head injury
History of electroconvulsive treatment (ECT) AlcohoUsubstance abusdwithdrawal
Reduced renamepatic drug elimination capacity
apine has str
antidepressant induced seizures
h increased ri
High dose/plasma level of antidepressant or metabolites Overdose of antidepressant
Rapid dose escalation
Concurrent use of drugs that lower seizure threshold
Concurrent use of drugs that inhibit metabolism of antidepressant
0, Suppl. 10
and drowsiness in 23% of patients, which is maximal in the first week but gradually reduces by weeks 3-4. How- ever, at higher doses ( 1 5 4 5 mg/day), mirtazapine in- creases norepinephrine, which produces arousal and thus tends to counteract some of the sedation (264). Vigilance and driving performance have also been reported to be impaired early in the course of treatment with mirtazap- ine, but tend to improve over the first few weeks (277). One study in normal volunteers found mirtazapine to
antidepressant, or changing medication before consider- ing introducing a counteracting agent, such as yohim- bine.
Epileptogenic potential. Seizures were first reported in people taking antidepressants in 1959, one year after the launch of the TCA imipramine (301). Since then, many studies and case reports have documented seizures with most non-MA0 inhibitor antidepressants. Many cli- nicians are therefore reluctant to prescribe much-needed medication to depressed patients with epilepsy or those at risk for seizures. However, many of the reports have been criticized for being retrospective, not clearly defin-
memory disturbance (281). Depression has also been shown to adversely affect memory and other cognitive functions (282). The older TCAs, especially amitripty- line, along with mianserin and trazodone, have been found to produce cognitive impairment and therefore should be avoided. The SSRIs (283) and mirtazapine (278)have not been shown to impair memory processes.
Sexual function. Sexual dysfunction (both impaired desire and performance) has been reported in both men and women with epilepsy (284-287). Diminished sexual satisfaction is often reported in outpatients suffering from depression (288). The reported incidence of sexual dysfunction associated with antidepressant treatment varies widely among studies and can affect libido, arousal, and orgasm (289). Balon et al. (290) found sex-
ual dysfunction in 43.3% and painful orgasm in 18% of male patients treated with antidepressants. They did not find that dysfunction was linked to any particular anti- depressant. TCAs, mianserin, M A 0 inhibitors, venlafax- ine, SSRIs (289) and reboxetine (data on file; Pharmacia and Upjohn, 1997) have all been found to cause dysfunc- tion (Table 7). Priapism, however, was mainly associated with trazodone (291). Sexual side effects appear to be highest with clomipramine, (over 90% in one study) and the SSRIs (292). Sexual dysfunction has been reported in 8-75% with fluoxetine (292), mainly anorgasmia, al- though retrograde ejaculation has also been reported with this drug (289). Sexual dysfunction appears to occur less commonly with the more selective serotonin inhibitor citalopram. However failure of ejaculation has been re- ported in 3.3% (293). Sexual dysfunction appears to oc- cur no more often with mirtazapine (294-297), nefaz- odone, or moclobemide than with placebo (289,298) (the latter has even been associated with an improvement in sexual functioning in some studies) (299). Assalian and Margolese (300) discussed the treatment of sexual dys- function associated with antidepressants. They advocate waiting for tolerance to develop, reducing the dose of
Some authors have suggested that various risk factors
may predispose to the precipitation of drug-induced sei-
zures and that these may be either patient- or drug-
related; see Table 4 (302,306,307). The patient-related predisposing factors have been documented in over half
the patients who experienced seizures when taking the
TCAs and buproprion (304,308).Another report has sug-
gested that patients at risk for developing seizures during psychotropic drug treatment can be identified by having
an enhanced amplitude of the early cortical somatosen-
sory evoked potentials (SSEPs) after median nerve stimulation (309). Other authors, however, have found
that antidepressant-induced seizures are predominantly
related to dose or plasma level (310,311). Preskorn and
Fast (3 11) also noted that they could not find any reports
of TCA-induced seizures at therapeutic plasma concen-
trations and concluded that patients who experienced convulsions at therapeutic doses of antidepressants were
likely to be slow metabolizers of the drugs. Seizures are
more likely to occur during the first week of antidepres-
sant treatment or after an increase in dose, especially
after rapid dose escalation (302). zy
have similar adverse effects on psychomotor and cogni-
tive effects as amitriptyline, and more mental slowness,
along with reduced tapping rate and flicker fusion fre-
quency, than diazepam (278). Clinical trials have shown ing a “seizure,” and including patients who have over- that citalopram (279) and venlafaxine (280) are not as- dosed on the antidepressant, taken other proconvulsant sociated with significantly higher sedation than with pla- medication, or who are at high risk for drug-induced
Memory. Patients with epilepsy often complain of The incidence of seizures occurring with therapeutic
doses of antidepressants varies from 0.1 to 4% (302). This needs to be compared to the annual incidence of first seizures in the general population, estimated at 0.073-0.086% (303).
Bupropion, a monocyclic antidepressant, was with- drawn in the United Kingdom in 1986 because of its proconvulsant properties but is still available in the United States. Patients taking >450 mg/day have been reported to have a seizure incidence of 0.35-0.44% (304). It has also been shown to cause agitation, insom- nia and nausea. A recent review (305) has suggested that the sustained release preparation (available since late 1996) may be less epileptogenic than the immediate re- lease version. Despite this, its use in patients with epi- lepsy is not recommended.
Other investigators have not found an increased inci-
S36 M. V. LAMBERT AND zM. M. ROyBERTSONxzwyxvwut
Of the older antidepressants, trazodone is believed to zures (325,328). Gigli et al. (329) administered 20-40 have little epileptogenic potential, either at therapeutic mg of fluoxetine to nine nondepressed patients with epi-
(317) or toxic (318) doses, and most reported cases of
TABLE 5. Data sheet recommendations for antidepressant use in patients with epilepsy
Amitriptyline Amoxapine Clomipramine
Desipramine Dothiepin Doxepin Imipramine
Lofepramine Nortriptyline Protriptyline Trimipramine Maprotiline
Mianserin Trazodone Viloxazine Isocarboxacid Phenelzine Tranylcypromine Moclobemide Fluvoxamine Fluoxetine
Paroxetine Citalopram Nefazodone Venlafaine Reboxetine Mirtazapine
zyxwv SIP, extreme caution in PWE or predisposing
Data sheet recommendation
convulsions have occurred in patients taking concorni- tant medication (317).
dence of seizures related to antidepressant medication
and some have even demonstrated improved control.
Ojemann et al. (312) retrospectively studied the effect of
at least 2-month treatment with doxepin on seizure fre-
quency in 19 patients with known epilepsy. Fifteen pa-
tients experienced a reduction in seizure frequency
(greater than 50% reduction in over half) and two re-
ported no change. Two patients experienced increased
seizures. However, they suffered from both partial and
generalized tonic-clonic seizures and, in each case, one
of the seizure types reduced in frequency on doxepin.
Robertson and Trimble (239) found no increase in sei-
zure frequency with concomitant treatment with amitrip-
tyline or nomifensine compared with placebo. Although
the bicyclic viloxazine has been associated with convul-
sions (313), other reports have shown it to have anticon-
vulsant potential in both animal studies (314) and clinical
use (261,315). Fromm et al. (316) reported improvement inabsenceandmyoclonic-astaticseizureswithimipra-zwithoyrshortlyafxteranotherdwrugknowntolovwertheu mine. seizure threshold (322-327) or in patients at risk of sei-
Irreversible MA0 inhibitors are generally considered to have less proconvulsant potential than the TCAs. The potential for drug interactions and the dietary restrictions (see Table 3), however, limits their use.
Reviews of the literature indicate that the older anti- depressants with the highest epileptogenic potential are the TCAs, especially amoxapine and clomipramine, along with bupropion (not available in the United King- dom), maprotiline, and mianserin (56,302,3 19). The data sheet recommendations for the use of antidepressants in people with epilepsy are shown in the Tables.
There have been reports of seizures with the SSRIs. However, these have mainly been single case studies (320,321) and often occur when the SSRI is administered
factors for epilepsy
SP. for oatients with low convulsion threshold (322,330), and all the SSRIs have been associated with
SIP, avoid if possible if history of epilepsy SP
SIP, extreme caution in PWE or predisposing
SIP, as dothiepin
SP, as dothiepin
C/I, known/suspected epilepsy or low convulsion
SIP, as dothiepin
SIP, great caution in PWE
SIP, discontinue if develop seizures
C/I, avoid if unstable epilepsy, carefully monitor
Discontinue if seizures develop
SIP, avoid if unstable epilepsy, carefully monitor
inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone (331- 340). Hyponatremia has been documented in 25% of elderly patients taking SSRIs (341) and diuretic co- medication may increase the risk (342,343). This should be considered when antidepressants are co-administered with another drug associated with hyponatremia, such as CBZ (344).
The newer antidepressants have also been shown to have either no effect or even anticonvulsant properties. In animal experiments, fluoxetine has been shown to enhance the anticonvulsant effects of PHT and CBZ (345). Fluoxetine produced complete seizure control in six and 30% reduction in 11 of 17 patients suffering from partial and/or secondarily generalized seizures (346). Fluoxetine administered to patients with learning disabil- ity, epilepsy, and aggressive behavior did not alter the frequency of seizures (347) and no significant procon- vulsant effect was reported in a major clinical trial of this drug (348). Fluvoxamine did not produce any change in seizure frequency nor EEG in 35 patients with epilepsy
SIP, discontinue if seizures develop
SIP, discontinue if seizures develop
SP (349). Paroxetine has also been shown not to affect sei-
five of who
zure frequency or the EEG (253,270,350), and preclini-
cal studies and clinical trials have not found sertraline to lepsy. be more epileptogenic than placebo (351). Preclinical
SP, special precaution; C/I, contraindicated; PWE, people with epi-
m had sym
lower dose, one improved, six remained unchanged, and twuo experietncedsincreaserd seizqures. Sevpen patienots were treated with the higher dose, and of these five remained unchanged and two worsened. After fluoxetine with-
ed to th
There have been several reports of antidepressant-
induced seizures in patients found to have hyponatremia
ency of s
normal volunteer studies did not find citalopram to have
a significant effect on the EEG ( 3 5 2 ) , and controlled
clinical trials have not shown it to precipitate seizures
(293).Blumer (353) recently advocated the use of SSRIs
in combination with TCAs for intractable depression in
patients with epilepsy, reporting a 68% good or excellent
response. Increased seizure frequency was noted only in
patients taking 200 mg TCA daily. Therefore, the author recommendedprescribingamaximumof150mg/day.Inzamitriyptyline(360x).Therefore,wfluvoxamineandvparox-u summary, most studies have revealed convulsions to oc- etine have a higher number of reported convulsions with
cur in up to 0.2% of patients taking SSRIs (354). respect to their market share than the other SSRIs, as Major clinical trials have also not found a significant does venlafaxine (360).
epileptogenic effect for venlafaxine (355), moclobemide
(356), or nefazodone (357) compared with placebo. In antidepressants and seizures and concluded that antide-
clinical studies, seizures were reported in 0.2% of pa- tients treated with reboxetine (data on file, Pharmacia and Upjohn, 1997) but may have been accounted for by other factors, including co-administration of other pro- convulsant medication. Only one patient of a possible 2,796 (0.035%) has been reported to experience a seizure while taking 80 mg of mirtazapine (the usual therapeutic dose being 15-45 mg/day). She had previously experi- enced seizures while taking clomipramine (358).
Table 5 shows the data sheet recommendations with respect to epilepsy (240). Table 6 shows the number of suspected drug reaction reports of “Convulsions and Epi- lepsy” associated with the Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs) and associated antidepressants. It is important to note that the receipt of a reaction by the Committee on Safety of MedicinesMedicines Control Agency (CSMMCA) does not necessarily mean that it has been caused by the drug as many factors have to be taken into account in assessing causal relationships in- cluding, temporal association, the possible contribution
of concomitant medication and the underlying disease. Many factors also influence the number of reports re- ceived and in most situations there is considerable “un- der-reporting’’ of reactions. It has been estimated from various surveys, (359) that only 10-15% of serious ad- verse reactions are reported (CSM-Personal communi- cation, July 1999). McConnell and Duncan (360) have discussed the difficulties encountered in evaluating CSM
Moclohemide Fluvoxamine Fluoxetine Sertraline Paroxetine Citalopram Nefazodone Venlafaxine
TABLE 6. Convulsions reported to CSM
No. of reports of ‘Status epilepticus’ (fatalities)
No.of reports of exacerhationhg gravation of seizures
all other reports of ‘Convulsions and epilepsy’
Total no. of reports (fatalities) (fatalities) received
zyx 8 (0) 7285
4 (0) 695
0 (0) 949 1 ( 0 ) 2228
3 (0) 523 2 (0) 2447
epines or other antidepressants), no deaths or seizures
were reported, even in the “frail elderly,” and the most
common outcome was sedation. There has been recent concern that citalopram may be more dangerous than other SSRIs in overdose (371). However, most of the patients had also ingested other drugs. Several workers
data. Factors influencing reporting patterns include how recently a drug has been introduced, media coverage, and whether the adverse reaction was expected. The market share of a given drug (which reflects the extent of usage) needs to be taken into account. Between 1991 and 1995, only six antidepressants accounted for over half the pre- scriptions dispensed in the United Kingdom, the most common being dothiepin, followed by fluoxetine and
pressant drugs have both convulsant and anticonvulsant properties, the anticonvulsant properties predominating at low doses and the convulsant at higher blood levels. These authors commented that antidepressant drugs are like several AEDs in that they can both prevent and cause seizures.
Safety in overdose
Frommer et al. (362) reviewed TCA overdoses in 2,536 patients from 26 studies and found a seizure inci- dence of 8.4%. Other studies have reported lower inci- dences and have noted that the epileptogenic potential varies among the antidepressants. Seizures have been reported in 3-8% of overdoses with TCAs (318,363). However, higher rates of 13% have been reported with dothiepin (364). Maprotiline, amoxapine, and citalopram appear to be particularly associated with seizures fol- lowing overdoses, with rates ranging from 12-77% for maprotiline (3 18,365,366), 24-36% with amoxapine (318,367) and in 18% taking 0.6-1.9 g and 47% taking I .9-5.2 g of citalopram (368).
Cassidy and Henry (369) calculated a “fatal toxicity
index,” deaths by acute poisoning per million NHS pre-
scriptions, and calculated that desipramine, tranylcypro-
mine, dothiepin, amitriptyline, nortriptyline, maprotiline,
doxepin, and imipramine were the most dangerous anti-
depressants. Swinkels and de Jonghe (237) stated that a
drug was “safe” when 14 times the therapeutic daily dose
(i.e., 2-week supply) was greater than the lethal dose.
Using this method, the SSRIs, moclobemide, rnianserin
and trazodone can be regarded as safe, and the TCAs as
less safe. Montgomery (294) summarized the 10 cases of
overdose that have been reported with mirtazapine. De-
spite in some cases more than a month’s supply being
ley and Nari
toku (361) r
eviewed the litera
ingested (always with co-medication, usually benzodiaz-
Epilepsia, Vol. 40. Suppl. 10. 1999
M. V. LAMBERT
Interactions with AEDs
NC A/M N C AIM + – + NC AIM
Isocarboxacid Phenelzine Tranylcypromine Moclobemide Fluvoxamine Fluoxetine Sertraline Paroxetine Citalopram Nefazodone Venlafaine Reboxetine Mirtazapine
1BP – Stimulant ++ – + Cheese reaction, 1BP
of adverse ev
depressants in pati
ztysxrw psychomotor retardation dysfunction potential from OD Other side effects
Sedation memory Sexual Epileptogenic Risk
– 2/52 Supply
++ ++ ++ + ++ ++ +
– Stimulant ++ – + Cheese reaction,
– Improves sleep – Anxiety, insomnia – Anxiety, insomnia – Anxiety, insomnia +
++ – – –
– 2/52 Supply
Cheese reaction, 5 BP
ents with anti
ents with epile
Amitriptyline + ++ + + ++Seizures NC AIM
+ + + + + +
+ + ++ ++Seizures NC
Nortriptyline + + + Protriptyline + – Stimulant +
++ ++ ++ +Seizures NC AIM
+ + ++ + ++ + ++
+ ++Seizures NC AIM ++ ++ Seizures NC AIM – ++Seizures NC AIM ++Seizures A/C A/M + Seizures NC AIM -/+ ++Seizures NC AIM N C AIM Trimipramine + ++ + + +Seizures NC AIM
+low dose ++high dose -/+
Maprotiline + ++ + ++ ++Seizures NC
-/+ + Seizures
+ +Improves sleep, impairs driving – – – Anxiety, insomnia ++ – – +
AEDs, antidepressants; OD, overdose; CA, contraindicated; AIC, anticholinergic; AIM, antimuscarinic; 1BP, hypotension; ?, increased; – 2/52 supply, no fatalities when 2 week supply ingested; +, more than (>) placebo: ++, >> placebo; -, same as placebo; -I+, differing reports, some < and some same as placebo.
have questioned the cause of death and have stressed the importance of limiting the total number of tablets dis- pensed (372,373).
In summary, all the antidepressants appear to be ef- fective for treatment of depression in patients with epi- lepsy. All have variable rates of adverse events, which are shown in Table 7. The studies have used different methods for assessing and diagnosing adverse effects. Therefore, they cannot be directly compared and sum- mated. Thus, in Table 7, “++” refers to an adverse event being definitely present, “+” refers to an adverse expe- rience occurring more than with placebo, and “-“means no documented increase in the side effect compared with placebo. Choice of antidepressant depends on the char-
acteristics and requirements of the individual patient. For example, activation may be preferred in patients with psychomotor retardation and slight sedation in patients with agitation or anxiety.
Lithium is frequently prescribed for the treatment and prophylaxis of bipolar affective disorder and is also li- censed for the prophylaxis of recurrent depression. Controversy exists as to the proconvulsant properties of lithium, despite small open studies failing to demon- strate adverse effects in patients with epilepsy (374,375). Several studies have reported seizures in patients treated with lithium at both toxic (376-379) and therapeutic
++ + ++ -/+ ++ – ++ +
on 7 Weight
– 2/52 Supply
Nausea, dizziness – 2/52 S ~ p p l y Nausea, vomiting – 2/52 Supply Nausea, vomiting – 2/52 Supply Nausea, vomiting – 2/52 Supply Nausea, vomiting
rqzypxw + -/+ Nausea
– -I+ Dry mouth, nausea
-F -/+ Dry mouth, constipation
e Dry mouth
serum levels (377,380-385). EEG changes have also been reported in patients (378,385,386) and in nor- mal volunteers (387). A recent article included pre- existing EEG abnormalities as a risk factor for the de-
lactic in the control of manic-depressive illness (112-
l precaution” in th
131) and gabapentin (134,135). Therefore, these AEDs should be used for the treatment of epilepsy in patients with co-existent bipolar disorder and additional therapy with lithium may be avoided.
ECT is not contraindicated in patients with epilepsy
and may be life-saving in those with severe or psychotic depression not responding to antidepressants (212). It has even been found to be safe after temporal lobectomy (172). There have been reports of spontaneous seizures in patients after ECT (389,390). However, major studies have found the incidence of spontaneous seizures fol- lowing ECT to be lower than the incidence of epilepsy in the general population (391,392). Hsiao et al. (393) re- ported the complications in 98 patients with epilepsy who received ECT and found an increase in seizure fre- quency in only one patient and the development of status epilepticus in two. Studies have also shown that the sei-
zure threshold tends to rise by an average of 80% (range 25-200%) during the course of treatment (394), therefore some workers consider ECT to be an effective anticon- vulsant (395,396). The efficacy of ECT may be reduced if AEDs decrease the intensity of the induced seizures
dose and gradually increased, and they should be con- tinued for at least 4 months after complete clinical re- covery. Other medication known to reduce the seizure threshold should be avoided. Patients and AED levels should be carefully monitored. If seizures develop, the patient should be changed to an antidepressant with lower risk. Patients with severe, uncontrolled epilepsy or who develop exacerbation of seizures may be best man-
aged as inpatients. ECT is not contraindicated in people with epilepsy and may be life-saving.
1. Lewis AJ. Melancholia: a historical review. J Men? Sci 1934;80: 1-42.
2. Barraclough B. Suicide and epilepsy. In: Reynolds FH, Trimble MR, eds. Epilepsy and psychiatry. Edinburgh: Churchill-Living- stone, 1981:72-6.
3. Harris EC, Barraclough B. Suicide as an outcome for mental disorders. A meta-analysis. Br J Psychiatry 1997;170:205-28.
4. Robertson MM. Suicide, parasuicide, and epilepsy. In: Engel J Jr,
Pedley TA, eds. Epilepsy: a comprehensive textbook. Philadel-
phia: Lippincott-Raven, 1997.
5. Mackay A. Self-poisoning: a complication of epilepsy. Br J Psy-
DEPRESSION IN EPILEPSY
choice of antidepressant is dictated by drug interactions, side-effect profile, effect on seizure threshold, and safety issues.
The older antidepressants, especially the TCAs, ap- velopmentofneurotoxicityattherapeuticlithiumlevelszpeartoylowerseizuxrethresholdw,especiallyinvulvnerableu
(388). individuals. There is less evidence for such an effect with Carbamazepine has been shown to be efficacious as an the newer antidepressants, especially moclobemide and antidepressant in patients without epilepsy and prophy- citalopram, which are the only drugs that do not cite
e data 114), as have VPA (112,114-116), lamotrigine (129- sheet. Antidepressants should be introduced at a low
(397).Therefore, Weiner and Coffey (398) recommend
that, with the exception of patients at high risk for status Benson DF, Blumer D, eds. Psychiatric Aspects of Neurological
11. New Yor
epilepticus or with recent generalized tonic-clonic sei- zures, AEDs should be omitted the morning before each
Interictal depression is common, occurring at some time in up to two-thirds of patients, especially those with severe andor frequent seizures. Etiologic factors include CPS, AEDs (especially PB and VGB), and psychosocial factors. The depression tends to be endogenous, accom- panied by agitation and impulsive suicidal behavior. Pa- tients with epilepsy tend to have fewer neurotic traits but more psychotic ones, such as paranoia, delusions, and persecutory auditory hallucinations.
Treatment includes improving seizure control by re- assessing AED medication. Support groups a n d o r psy- chotherapy are sufficient to treat depressive reactions. However, antidepressants are usually necessary for treat- ing depressive illness in patients with epilepsy. The
y as a reaso
n for “specia
6. Hawton K, Fazgg J, Marsacyk P. Associatxion between ewpilepsy and
Raven Press, 1977:27-34.
9. Jensen I, Larsen JK. Mental aspects of temporal lobe epilepsy,
follow-up of 74 patients after resection of a temporal lobe. J
Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1979;42:256-65.
10. Obafunwa JO, Busuttil A. Clinical contact preceding suicide.
attempted suicide. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1980;43:168-
7. Blumer D, Benson DF. Psychiatric manifestations of epilepsy. In:
k: Grune and
ies in epilepsy: with a note on the cause of death. In: Penry JK,
8. Taylor DC, Marsh SM. Implications of long-term follow-up stud-
ium. New Y
Postgrad Med J 1994;70:428-32.
1, Devinsky 0,Bear DM. Varieties of depression in epilepsy. Neu-
zures. J Nerv Meat Dis 1986;174:471-6.
4. Hughes J, Devinsky 0,Feldmann E, Bromfield E. Premonitory
symptoms in epilepsy seizure. 1993;2:201-3.
15. Williams D. The structure of emotions reflected in epileptic ex-
periences. Brain 1956;79:2947.
16. Weil AA. Ictal emotions occurring in temporal lobe dysfunction.
Arch Neurol 1959;1:87-97. 17.Devinsky0,FeldmannE,BromfieldE,EmotoS,RaubertisR.
Structured interview for simple partial seizures: clinical phenom- enology and diagnosis. J Epilepsy 1991;4:107-16.
ropsychiatry Neuropsychol Behav Neurol 1991;4:49-61.
2. Grule HW. Epileptische Reaktionen und epileptische Krank- heiten. In: Bumke 0 , ed. Handbuch der Geistenkrankheiten. Vol.
18. Spezieller Teil
3. Blanchet P, Frommer GP. Mood change preceding epileptic sei-
Epilepsia, Vol. 4
0, Suppl. 1
zsyrxqwpvo 18. Lim J, Yagnik P, Schraeder P, Wheeler S. Ictal catatonia as a early postsurgical psychiatric associations of epilepsy surgery.I
prevent seizures: Countermeasures or cue-controlled arousal ma- nipulation? Is there something special about smell? [Abstract]. Epilepsia 1995;36(suppl 3):S25.
23. Goldstein LH. Effectiveness of psychological interventions for people with poorly controlled epilepsy. J Neurol Neurosurg Psy- chiatry 1997;63:13743.
24. Blumer D. Postictal deoression: significance for the n
ioral disorder of epilepsy. J Epilepsy 1992;5:214-9.
25 Devinsky 0 , Kelley K, Yacubian EMT, Sato S, Kufta CV, The- odore WH. Postictal behavior. A clinical and subdural electroen-
cephalographic study. Arch Neurol 1994;51:254-9.
26 Hurwitz TA, Wada JA, Kosaka BD, Strauss EH. Cerebral orga- nization of affect suggested by temporal lobe seizures. Neurology
50. Fiordelli E, Beghi E, Bogliun G, Crespi V. Epilepsy and psychi-
30. 31. 32.
36. 37. 38.
Currie S, Heathfield W, Henson R, Scott D. Clinical course and prognosis of temporal lobe epilepsy: a survey of 666 patients. Brain 1971;94:173-90.
Taylor DC. Mental state and temporal lobe epilepsy, a correlative account of 100 patients treated surgically. Epilepsia 1972;13: 727-65.
Standage KF, Fenton GW. Psychiatric symptom profiles of pa- tients with epilepsy: a controlled investigation. Psycho1 Med 19735:152-60.
Roy A. Some determinants of affective symptoms in epileptics. Can J Psychiatry 1979;24:554-6.
Mendez MF, Cummings JL, Benson DF. Depression in epilepsy. Significanceandphenomenology.ArchNeurol 1986;43:766-70. Brown SW, McGowan MEL, Reynolds EH. The influence of seizure type and medication on psychiatric symptoms in epileptic patients. Br J Psychiatry 1986;148:30M.
Edeh J, Toone B. Relationship between interictal psychopathol- ogy and type of epilepsy. Results of a survey in general practice. Br J Psychiatry 1987;151:95-101.
Edeh J, Toone BK, Corney RH. Epilepsy, psychiatric morbidity, and social dysfunction in general practice. Comparison between clinic patients and clinic nonattenders. Neuropsychiatry Neuro-
psycho1 Behav Neurol. 1990;3:180-92.
Victoroff JI, Benson DF, Engel J Jr, Grafton S, Mazziotta JC.
Interictal depression in patients with medically intractable com-
plex partial seizures: electroencephalography and cerebral meta-
bolic correlates [Abstract]. Ann Neurol 1990;28:221,
Gureje 0. Interictal psychopathology in epilepsy. Prevalence and
pattern in a Nigerian clinic. Br J Psychiatry 1991;158:700-5.
Indaco A, Carrieri PB, Nappi C, Gentile S, Striano S. Interictal
depression in epilepsy. Epilepsy Res 1992;12:45-50.
Victoroff JI, Benson DF, Grafton ST, Engel J Jr, Mazziotta JC.
Depression in complex partial seizures. Electroencephalography
and cerebral metabolic correlates. Arch Neurol 1994;51:155-63.
Robertson MM, Channon S, Baker J. Depressive symptomatolo-
gy in a general hospital sample of outpatients with temporal lobe
N, Potts P,
r and non-ps
ings from a U.K. community study. Epilepsia 1996;37:14841. 42. Baker GA, Jacoby A, Chadwick DW. The associations of psy- chopathology in epilepsy: a community study. Epilepsy Res 1996
. V. LAMBERT
AND M. M
methods in outpatient management. Epilepsia 1990;31 zyxwvuqp
manifestation of nonconvukive status epilepticus. J Neural Neu- Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1998;64:60 1
rosurg Psychiatry 1986;49:833-6. 44. Blumer D, Wakhlu S, Davies K, Hermann B. Psychiatric outcome 19. Betts TA. Neuropsychiatry. In: Laidlaw J, Richens A, Chadwick of temporal lobectomy for epilepsy: incidence and treatment of
of epilepsy. 4
Livingstone, 1993:397458. 45. Boyd JH, Weissman MM. Epidemiology. In: Paykel ES, ed.
D, eds. A textbook
th ed. Edinb
20. Mendez MF, Doss RC. Ictal and psychiatric aspects of suicide in Handbook of Affective Disorders. New York: The Guildford epileptic patients. Int J Psychiatry Med 1992;22:231-7. Press, 1982;109-25.
21. Gillham FL4. Refractory epilepsy: an evaluation of psychological 46. Kogeorgos J, Fonagy P, Scott DF. Psychiatric symptom patterns
22. Betts T, Fox C, MacCallum R. Using olfactory stimuli to abort or investigation. Br J Psjchiatry 1982;140:23643.
49. Trostle JA, Hauser A, Sharbrough FW. Psychologic and social adjustment to epilepsy in Rochester, Minnesota. Neurologj 1989;39:633-7.
66. Meldrum BS. Neurochemical substrates of ictal behavior. In: Smith DB, Treiman DM, eds. Neurobehaviorul problems in epi- 40.ManchandaR,SchaeferB,McLachlanRS,etal.Psychiatricdis- lepsy.(Advancesinneurology,~0155)N.ewYork:RavenPress,
orders in candidates for surgery for epilepsy. J Neurol Neurosurg 1991: 3 5 4 5 .
Psychiatry 1996;61:82-9. 67. Mignone RJ, Dannelly EF, Sadowsky D. Psychological and neu-
clinical course of epilepsy and its psychosocial correlates: find- leptic patients. Epilepsia 1970;11:345-59.
68. Deleted in proof.
69. Dikmen S, Hermann BP, Witensky AJ, Rainwater G. Validity of
the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) to psy- 25:29-39z.ychopathologyinpatientswithepilepsy.JNervMen?Dis1983;
0, Suppl. 10
47. Mendez MF, Doss RC, Taylor JL, Salguero P. Depression in epilepsy. Relationship to seizures and anticonvulsant therapy. J Nerv Ment Dis 1993;181:444-7.
48. Pond D, Bidwell B, Stein L. A survey of 14 general practices. Part I: Medical and demographic data. Psychiatr Neurol Neurochir 1959/60;63:217-36.
51. Altshuler LL, Devinsky 0 , Post RM, Theodore W. Depression,
anxiety, and temporal lobe epilepsy. Laterality of focus and
symptoms. Arch Neurol 1990;47:284-8.
52. Strauss E, Wada J, Moll A. Depression in male and female sub-
jects with complex partial seizures. Arch Neurol I992;49:391-2. 53. Septien L, Grass P, Giroud M, et al. Depression and temporal lobe epilepsy: the possible role of laterality of the epileptic foci and
gender. Neurophysiol Clin 1993;23:326-7.
54. Robertson MM, Trimble MR, Townsend HRA. Phenomenology
of depression in epilepsy. Epilepsia 1987;28:364-72.
55. Hermann BP, Whitman S. Psychosocial predictors of interictal
depression. J Epilepsy 1989;2:231-7.
56. Robertson MM. Depression in neurological disorders. In: Rob-
ertson MM, Katona CLE, eds. Depression and physical illness.
Chichester: John Wiley, 1997:305-40.
57. Lishman WA. Organic psychiatry. The psychological conse-
quences ofcerebral disorder. 3rd ed. Oxford: Blackwell Science, 1998.
58. Koch-Weser M, Garron DC, Gilley DW, et al. Prevalence of psychologic disorders after surgical treatment of seizures. Arch Neurol 1988;45:1308-11.
Hermann BP, Wyler AR. Depression, locus of control, and the effects of epilepsy surgery. Epilepsia 1989;30:332-8.
61. 62. 63.
Murray RE, Abou-Khalil B, Griner L. Evidence for familial as- sociation of psychiatric disorders and epilepsy. Bid Psychiatry 1994;36:428-9.
Thompson PJ, Oxley J. Socioeconomic accompaniments of se- vere epilepsy. Epilepsia 1988;29(suppl 1):S9-18.
Lund J. Epilepsy and psychiatric disorder in the mentally retarded adult. Acta Psychiatr Scand 1985;72:55742.
Steffenberg S, Gillberg C , Steffenberg U. Psychiatric disorders in children and adolescents with mental retardation and active epi- lepsy. Arch Neurol 1996;53:904-12.
Deb S, Hunter D. Psychopathology of people with mental handi- cap and epilepsy 11: Psychiatric illness. Br J Psychiatry 1991; 159:826-30.
Pary R. Mental retardation, mental illness, and seizure diagnosis. Am J Ment Retard 1993;98:S58-62.
tics attending a ne
nic: a controlled
atric disturbance. A cross-sectional study. Br
43. Ring HA, Moriarty J, Trimble MR. A prospective study of the 171:114-22.
71. Gibbs FA. Ictal and non-ictal psychiatric disorders in temporal lobe epilepsy. J Nerv Ment Dis 1951;11:522-8.
97. Gallhofer B, Trimble MR, Frackiowiak R, Gibbs J, Jones T. A
al study o
f clinical an
graphic manifestations of 536 psychotic episodes occurring in
5I6 epileptics between clinical seizures. Epilepsia 1959/60;1
73. Rodin EA, Rim CS, Kitano H, et al. A comparison of the effec-
tiveness of primidone versus carbamazepine in epileptic outpa-
tients. J Nerv Ment Dis 1976;163:41-6.
74. Perini GI, Tosin C, Carraro C, et al. Interictal mood and person-
ality disorders in temporal lobe epilepsy. J Neurol Neurosurg
75. Small JG, Milstein V, Stevens JR. Are psychomotor epileptics
different? A controlled study. Arch Neurol 1962;7:187-94.
76. Stevens JR. Psychiatric implications of psychomotor epilepsy.
Arch Gen Psychiatry 1966;14:461-71.
77. Hermann BP, Seidenberg M, Haltiner A, Wyler AR. Mood state
in unilateral temporal lobe epilepsy. Biol Psychiatry 1991;30:
78. Bromfield EB, Altshuler L, Leiderman DB, et al. Cerebral me-
tabolism and depression in patients with complex partial seizures.
Arch Neurol 1992;49:617-23.
79. Trimble M, Perez M. The phenomenology of the chronic psycho-
ses of epilepsy. Adv Biol Psychiatry 1980;8:98-105.
80. Manchanda R, Schaefer B, McLachlan RS, Blume WT. Interictal psychiatric morbidity and focus of epilepsy in treatment refrac-
tory patients admitted to an epilepsy unit. Am J Psychiatry 1992;
81. Manchanda R, Schaefer B, McLachlan RS, Blume WT. Relation-
ship of site of seizure focus to psychiatric morbidity. J Epilepsy
;48:201-6. JC, Engel JE
82. Flor-Henry P. Psychosis and temporal lobe epilepsy: a controlled
Dominian J, Serafetinides GA, Dewhurst M. A follow-up study of late-onset epilepsy: I1 Psychiatric and social findings. BMJ 1963; 1:431-5.
Nielsen H, Kristensen 0. Personality correlates of sphenoidal EEG-foci in temporal lobe epilepsy. Actn Neurol Scand 1981;64:289-300.
Perini G, Mendius R. Depression and anxiety in complex partial seizures. J Nerv Ment Dis 1984;172:287-90.
Mendez MF, Taylor JL, Doss RC, Salguero P. Depression in secondary epilepsy: relation to lesion laterality. J Neurol Neuro- surg Psychiatry 1994;57:232-3.
Seidenberg M, Hermann B, Noe A, Wyler AR. Depression in temporal lobe epilepsy. Interaction between laterality of lesion and Wisconsin Card Sort performance. Neuropsychiatry Neuro- psycho1 Behav Neurol 1995;8:81-87.
Robertson M. Mood disorders associated with epilepsy. In: Mc- Connell HW, Snyder PJ, eds. Psychiatric comorbidity in epilepsy. Basic mechanisms, diugnosis, and treatment. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, 1998:132-67.
Flor-Henry P. On certain aspects of the localisation of the cere- bral systems regulating and determining emotion. Biol Psychiatry
Deleted in proof.
Engel J Jr, Kuhl DE, Phelps ME, Mazziotta JC. Interictal cerebral glucose metabolism in partial epilepsy and its relation to electro- encephalographic changes. Ann Neurol 1982;12:510-7.
110. Dalby MA. Behavioural effects of carbamazepine. In: Penry JK, Daly DD, eds. Advances in neurology II. New York: Raven Press, 1975:331-44.
70. Dodrill CB, Batzel LW. Inter-ictal behavioural features of pa- tients with epilepsy. Epilepsh 1986;27(suppI 2):S64-76.
frontal glucose metabolism common to three types of depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1989;46:243-50.
en. J Neurol vuts
106. Smith DB, Collins JB. Behavioral effects of carbamazepine, phe- zyxw nobarbital, phenytoin and primidone [Abstract]. Epilepsia 1987;
investigation. Epilepsia 1969;10:363-95.
83. Deleted in proof.
84. Rodin E, Schmaltz S. The Bear-Fedio personality inventory and
temporal lobe epilepsy. Neurology 1984;34:591-6.
ment and major depressive disorder in children with epilepsy. Puediatrics 1987;80:909-17.
lobe epilepsy: an examination of psychopathology and psycho- social behaviour. J Epilepsy 1991;4:157-64.
86. Sackheim H, Greenberg MS, Weiman AL, Gur RC Hungers- buhler JP, Geschwind N. Hemisoheric asvmmetrv in the exores- sion of positive and negative emotion. Arch Neurol 1982;39:210-1 8.
A, Stagno SJ,
Lalli J. Unilat
96. Baxter LR, Schwartz JM, Phelps ME, et al. Reduction of pre-
new referrals with epilepsy. Epilepsia 1986;27:128-34.
112. Emrich HM, Dose M, yon Zerssen D. The use of sodium valpro- ate, carbamazepine and oxcarbazepine in patients with affective
disorders. J Affect Disord 1985;8:243-50.
113. Post RM, Uhde TW, Joffe RT, Roy-Byrne PP, Kellner C. Anti-
convulsant drugs in psychiatric illness: new treatment alternatives and theoretical implications. In: Trimble MR, ed. The psycho-
pharmacology of epilepsy. Chichester: Wiley, 1985:141-7 1.
114. Fenwick PBC. Antiepileptic drugs and their psychotropic effects.
Epilepsia 1992;33(suppl 6):S33-6.
115. McElroy SL, Keck PE, Pope HG. Sodium valproate: its use in
primary psychiatric disorders. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1987;7:
116. Balfour JA, Bryson HM. Valproic acid. A review of its pharma-
cology and therapeutic potential in indications other than epi-
lepsy. CNS Drugs 1994;2:144-73.
117. Sander JWAS, Duncan JS. Vigabatrin. In: Shorvon S, Dreifuss F,
Fish D, Thomas D, eds. The treatment of epilepsy. Oxford: Black-
well Science, 1996:491-9.
118. Ring HA, Crellin R, Kirker S, Reynolds EH. Vigabatrin and
depression. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1993;56:925-8.
119. Reunanen M, Dam M, Yuen A. A randomised open multicentre comparative trial of lamotrigine and carbamazepine as mono-
108. Dodrill CB. Behavioral effects of antiepileptic drugs. In: Smith D, Treiman D, Trimble M, eds. Advances in Neurology. Vol. 55. New York: Raven Press, 1991:213-24.
study of cerebral blood flow and metabolism in epileptic psycho-
anatomy of mesial temporal lobe epilepsy. Arch Neurol 1993;50: 582-9.
99. Schmitz EB, Moriarty J, Costa DC, Ring HA, Ell PJ, Trimble MR. Psychiatric profiles and patterns of cerebral blood flow in focal epilepsy: interactions between depression, obsessionality, and perfusion related to the laterality of the epilepsy. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1997;62:458-63.
100. Wyler AR, Richey ET, Hermann BP. Comparison of scalp to subdural recordings for localising epileptogenic foci. J Epilepsy 1989;2:91-6.
phy and oxyg
101. Bear D, Fedio P. Quantitative analysis of interictal behaviour in temporal lobe epilepsy. Arch Neurol 1977;34:454-67.
102. Betts TA. A follow-up study of a cohort of patients with epilepsy admitted to psychiatric care in an English city. In: Harris, P,
Mawdsley C, eds. Epilepsy-proceedings
Centenary Symposium. Churchill Livingston, Edinburgh. 1974: 326-38.
103. Roth DL, Goode KT, Williams VL, Faught E. Physical exercise, stressful life experience, and depression in adults with epilepsy. Epilepsia 1994;35:1248-55.
104. Baker GA, Nashef L, van Hout BA. Current issues in the man- agement of epilepsy: the impact of frequent seizures on cost of illness, quality of life and mortality. Epilepsia 1995;38(suppI 1): s1-8.
105. Shorvon S, Reynolds EH. Reduction in polypharmacy for epi- lepsy. BMJ 1979;2:1023-5.
107. Brent DA, Crumrine PK, Varma RR, et al. Phenobarbital treat-
109. Smith DB. Cognitive effects of AEDs. In: Smith DB, Treiman DM, eds. Neurobehavioral problems in epilepsy. Advances in neurology. Vol. 55. New York: Raven Press, 1991:197-212.
of the Ha
n JG, Tomli
nson L, et al. A
study of the cognitive effects of phenytoin and carbamazepine in
Epilepsiu, Vol. 40, Suppl. 10. 1999
S42 zyxwM. V. LAMBERvT AND Mu. M. ROBERtTSONszryqxpwov
therapy in patients with newly diagnosed or recurrent epilepsy.
Epilepsy Res 1996;23:149-55.
120. Betts T. Lamotrigine in the context of non-pharmacological thera-
pies for epilepsy. Rev Contemp Pharmacother 1994;5:141-6.
121. Bisgaard C, Dalby M, Mai J. Lamictal as add-on antiepileptic drug in 210 patients with resistant epilepsy [Abstract]. Epilepsia
122. Wohlfarth R, Saar J, Reinshagen G. Behavioural effects of la-
motrigine [Abstract]. Epilepsia 1994;35(suppl 7):S72.
123. Gustev EI, Burd GS. Lamictal in treatment of patients with drug-
resistant epilepsy. Epilepsia 1994;36(suppl 3):S165-6.
124. Mouzichouck L, Maryek G, Obukhova H. Lamotrigine in patients with treatment-resistant epilepsy [Abstract]. Epilepsia 1995;
vulsant drugs, and psychiatric morbidity. Clin Neurophamacol 1995;18:165-82.
Klipstein FA. Subnormal serum folate and macrocytosis associ- ated with anticonvulsant drug therapy. Blood 1964;23:68-86.
Reynolds EH, Chanarin I, Milner G, Matthews DM. Anticonvul- sant therapy, folic acid and vitamin B,, metabolism, and mental symptoms. Epilepsia 1966;7:261-70.
Goggin T, Gough H, Bissessar A, Crowley M, Baker M, Cal- laghan C. A comparative study of the relative effects of anticon- vulsant drugs and dietary folate on the red cell folate status of patients with epilepsy. Q J Med 1987;65:911-9.
36(suppl 3):S114. therapy. Epilepsy Res 1992;13:89-92.
125. Smith D, Baker G, Davies G, Dewey M, Chadwick DW. Out- 150. Camey MWP. Serum folate values in 423 psychiatric patienls.
comes of add-on treatment with lamotrigine in partial epilepsy. BMJ 1967;4:5124.
Epilepsia 1993;34:312-22. 151. Camey MWP, Chary TKN, Laundy M, et al. Red cell folate
126. Gillham R, Baker G, Thompson P, et
self-report questionnaire for use in evaluating cognitive, affective 207-13.
and behavioural side-effects of anti-epileptic drug treatments.
Epilepsy Res 1996;24:47-55.
127. Gillham RA, Kane K, Bryant-Comstock L. Relationship between
side effect and life satisfaction (SEALS) score, seizure occur- rence and side effects to treatment in newly diagnosed patients with epilepsy [Abstract]. Epilepsia 1997;38(suppl 3):S163.
152. Godfrey PSA, Toone BK, Carney MWP, et al. Enhancement of recovery from psychiatric illness by methylfolate. Lancet 1990, 336:392-5.
153. Reynolds EH. Effects of folk acid on the mental state and fit- frequency of drug-treated epileptic patients. Lancet 1967;1: 1086-8.
154. Crellin R, Bottiglieri T, Reynolds EH. Folates and psychiatric disorders. Clinical potential. Drugs 1993;45:623-36.
155. Chanarin I, Laidlaw J, Loughridge LW, Mollin DL. Megaloblas- tic anaemia due to phenoharbitone. The convulsant action of therapeutic doses of folic acid. BMJ 1960;l:1099.
156. Rausch R, Crandall PH. Psychological status related to surgical control of temporal lobe seizures. Epilepsia 1982;23:191-202.
157. Hermann BP, Wyler AR, Ackerman B, Rosenthal T. Short-term psychological outcome of anterior temporal lobectomy. J Neu-
128. Steiner T. Comparison of lamotrigine and phenytoin mono- therapy in newly diagnosed epilepsy [Abstract]. Epilepsia 1994; 35(snppl 8):S31.
Walden J, Hesslinger B, van-Calker D, Berger M. Addition of lamotrigine to valproate may enhance efficacy in the treatment of bipolar affective disorder. Pharmacopsychiatry 1996;29:193-5. Calabrese JR, Fatemi SH, Woyshville MJ. Antidepressant effects of lamotrigine in rapid cycling bipolar disorder [Letter]. Am J Psychiatry 1996;153:1236.
a systematic review of their efficacy and tolerability. BMJ 1996; intractable seizures: a 20-30 year follow-up of 14 cases. Psycho1 313:1169-74. Med 1990;20:52945.
Sporn J, Sachs G. The anticonvulsant lamotrigine in treatment- reosurg l989;71:327-34.
resistant manic-depressive illness. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1997; 158. Hermann BP, Wyler AR, Somes G. Preoperative psychological
17:185-9. adjustment and surgical outcome are determinants of psychoso- 132. Shorvon S, Stefan H. Overview of the safety of newer antiepi- cia1 status after anterior temporal lobectomy. J Neurol Neurosurg
leptic drugs. Epilepsia 1997;38(suppl 1):S45-5
133. Marson AG, Kadir ZA, Chadwick DW. New antiepileptic drugs: 159. Stevens JR. Psychiatric consequences of temporal lobectomy for
134. Ryback RS, Brodsky L, Munasilfi F. Gabapentin in bipolar dis- 160. Seidman-Ripley JG, Bound VK, Andermann F, Olivier
order. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci 1997;9:301. P, Feindel WH. Psychosocial consequences of postoperative sei-
135. Schaffer CB, Schaffer LC. Gabapentin in the treatment of bipolar disorder. Am J Psychiatry 1997;154:291-2.
136. Numberger JI Jr, Berrettini WH, Simmons-Alling S, Guroff JJ, Gershon ES. Intravenous GABA administration is anxiolytic in man. Psychiatry Res 1986;19:113-7.
zure relief. Epilepsia 1993;34:248-54.
161. Kellett MW, Smith DF, Baker GA, Chadwick DW. Quality of life
after epilepsy surgery. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1997;63:
162. Hill D, Pond DA, Mitchell W, Falconer MA. Personality changes
149. Sander JW, Patsalos PN. An assessment of serum and red blood cell folate concentrations in patients with epilepsy on lamotrigine
c patients. J zyxwvutsrqp
137.LeppikIE.Tiagabine:thesafetylandscape.Epilepsia1995; followingtemporallobectomyforepilepsy.zJMentSci195y7;103:x 6(suppl 6):S10-3. 18-27.
138. Stephen LJ, Brodie MJ. New drug treatments for epilepsy. Pre- 163. Bladin PF. Psychosocial difficulties and outcome after temporal scribers J 1998;38:98-106. lobectomy. Epilepsia 1992;33:898-907.
ated for epilepsy surgery. Med Care 1992;30:299-319.
165. Fenwick P. Long-term psychiatric outcome after epilepsy sur- gery. In: Liiders H, ed. Epilepsy surgery. New York: Raven Press,
166. Naylor AS, Rogvi-Hansen B, Kessing L, Kruse-Larsen C. Psy-
chiatric morbidity after surgery for epilepsy: short-term follow up of patients undergoing amygdalohippocampectomy. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1994;57: 1375-81.
167. Falconer MA, Serafetinides EA. A follow-up study of surgery in
temporal lobe epilepsy. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry I963;26: zy 154-63.
168. Bruton CJ. The neuropathology of temporal lobe epilepsy. Maudsley monographs. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988. 169. Krahn LE, Rummans TA, Peterson GC, Cascino GD, Sharbrough FW.Electroconvulsive therapy for depression after temporal lo-
bectomy for epilepsy. Case report. Convulsive Ther 1993;9:
139. Leach JP, Brodie MJ. Drug profile: tiagabine. Lancet 1998;351: 164. Vickrey BG, Hays RD, Graber J, Rausch
203-7. RH. A health-related quality of life instrument for patients evalu-
140. Dodrill CB, Arnett JL, Shu V, Pixton GC, Lenz GT, Sommerville KW. Effects of tiagabine monotherapy on abilities, adjustment, and mood. Epilepsia 1998;39:33-42.
141. Kendrick AM, Duncan JS, Trimble MR. Effects of discontinua- tion of individual antiepileptic drugs on mood. Hum Psychophar- macol 1993;8:263-70.
142. Ketter TA, Malow BA, Flamini R, White SR, Post RM, Theodore WH. Anticonvulsant withdrawal emergent psychopathology. Neurology 1994;44:55-61.
143. Pratt JA, Jenner P, Johnson AL, Johnson AL, Shorvon SD, Reyn- olds EH. Anticonvulsant drugs alter plasma tryptophan concen- trations in epileptic patients: implications for antiepileptic action and mental function. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1984;47: 1131-3.
144. Edeh J, Toone BK. Antiepileptic therapy, folate deficiency and psychiatric morbidity: a general practice survey. Epilepsia 1985; 26:43440.
145. Froscher W, Maier V, Laage M, et al. Folate deficiency, anticon- 170. Parashos IA, Oxley SL, Boyko OB, Krishnan KRR. In vivo quan-
Epilepsia, Vol. 40, Suppl.
R,Engel J Jr,
172. Krahn LE, Rummans TA, Peterson
of surgical treatment of epilepsy. Mayo Clin Proc 1996;71:
DEPRESSION IN EPILEPSY s43 zy
hgfe social function following temporal lobectomy: influence of sei- 199. Treiman D. Psychobiology of ictal aggression. In: Smith DB,
zure control and learned helplessness. Seizure 1994;3:171-6. Treiman DM, ids. Neurobehavioral problems in epilepsy. Ad-
titation of basal ganglia and thalamic degenerative changes in two 197. Mark VH, Ervin FR. Violence and the brain. New York: Harper temporal lobectomy patients with affective disorder. J Neuropsy- and Row, 1970.
z CJ, M
n RS, Deny
m J Epilepsy
1201-4. 200 Arangio AJ. Behind the stigma of epilepsy. Washington, DC:
173. Ferguson SM, Rayport M. The adjustment to living without epi- lepsy. J New Ment Dis 1965;140:26-37.
174. Usiskin S. Counseling in epilepsy. In: Hopkins A, Shorvon S, Cascino G, eds. Epilepsy. 2nd ed. London: Chapman & Hall, 1995:565-7 1.
175. Thompson PJ. The rehabilitation of people with epilepsy. In: Hopkins A, Shorvon S, Cascino G, eds. Epilepsy. 2nd ed. Lon- don: Chapman & Hall, 1995:573-9.
176. Rausch R. Effects of temporal lobe surgery on behavior. In: Smith DB, Treiman DM, eds. Neurobehavioral vroblems in evilevsy.
Epilepsy Foundation of America, 1975.
201 Thompson P, Oxley J. Social aspects of epilepsy. In: Laidlaw J,
Advances in neurology. Vol. 55. New York: Raven Press, 1991:
177. Abramson LY, Seligman MEP, Teasdale JD. Learned helpless-
ness in humans: critique and reformulation. J Abnorm Psychol
178. Hermann BP. Psychopathology in epilepsy and learned helpless-
ness. Med Hypotheses 1979;5:723-9.
179. De Vellis RF, De Vellis BM, Wallston BS, Wallston KA. Epi-
lepsy and learned helplessness. Basic Appl Social Psychol 1980;
180. Hermann BP, Treneny MR, Colligan RC. Learned helplessness,
attributional style and depression in epilepsy. Epilepsia 1996;37:
i81. Hermann BP. Quality of life in epilepsy. J Epilepsy 1992;5:
182. Baker GA, Smith DF, Dewey M, Jacoby A, Chadwick DW. The
initial development of a health-related quality of life model as an
outcome measure in epilepsy. Epilepsy Res 1993;16:65-81.
183. Perrine K, Hermann BP, Meador KJ, et al. The relationship of neuropsychological functioning to quality of life in epilepsy. Arch
184. Rodin EA, Shaoiro HL. Lennox K. Euileosv and life oerfor-
209. 210. 211. 212.
Mittan R. Fear of seizures. In: Whitman S, Hermann BP, eds. Psychopathology in epilepsy: social dimensions. New York: Ox- ford University Press, 1986:90-121.
Mittan R. The influence of seizure-related variables upon pa- tients’ fears of death and brain damage [Abstract]. Epilepsia 1987;28:540.
Goldstein J, Seidenberg M, Peterson R. Fear of seizures and behavioral functioning in adults with epilepsy. J Epilepsy 1990; 3:lOl-6.
Mayou R, Hawton K. Psychiatric disorder in the general hospital. Br J Psychiatry 1986;149:172-90.
mance. Rehab Lit 1977;38:34-9.
185 Dodrill CB, Breyer DN, Diamond MB, Dubinsky BL, Geary BB.
Psychosocial problems among adults with epilepsy. Epilepsia
186 Greist JH, Klein MH, Eischens RR, Faris J, Gurman AL, Morgan
WP. Running for treatment of depression. Comprehens Psychia-
sion. J Personal SOCPsychol 1984;46:1142-7.
188. Roth DL. Acute emotional and psychophysiological effects of
aerobic exercise. Psychophysiology 1990;26:593-602.
189. Nakken KO, Bjorholt PG, Johannessen SI, L~yningT, Lind E. Effects of physical training on aerobic capacity, seizure occur- rence, and serum level of antiepileptic drugs in adults with epi-
lepsy. Epilepsia 1990;31:88-94.
190. Rutter M, Graham P, Yule W. A neuropsychiafric study in child-
hood. London: Heinemann, 1970.
191. Schneider JW, Conrad P. In the closet with illness: epilepsy,
stigma potential and information control. Social Probl 1980;28:
192. Long CG, Moore JR. Parental expectations for their epileptic
children. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 1979;20:299-3 12.
193. Hauck C. Sociological aspects of epilepsy research. Epilepsia
194. Goffman E. Stigma: notes on the management of spoiled identity.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1963.
195. Jacoby A. Felt versus enacted stigma: a concept revisited. Evi-
dence from a study of people with epilepsy in remission. Social
Sci Med 1994;38:269-74.
196. Lennox GW, Lennox MA. Epilepsy and related disorders. Vol. 1.
Boston: Little, Brown, 1960.
World Health Organisation. The ICD-I0 classification of mental
Edinburgh: Churchill-Livingstone, 1993:661-704.
202 Scambler G, Hopkins A. Generating a model of epileptic stigma. The role of qualitative analysis. Social Sci Med 1990;30:1187-94. 203 Ryan R, Kemper K, E d e n AC. The stigma of epilepsy as a
self-concept. Epilepsia 1980;21:433-44.
204. Arnston P. The perceived psychosocial consequences of having
epilepsy. In: Whitman S, Hermann B, eds. Psychopathology in epilepsy: social dimensions. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986:143-61. New York.
205. Scambler G, Hopkins A. Being epileptic: coming to terms with stigma. SOCHealth Illness 1986;8:26-43.
Richens A, Chadwick D, eds.
Roberts A. The use of antidepressant drugs in general practice. Prescriber 1995;5:35-53z.
Cunningham LA. Depression in the medically ill: choosing an antidepressant. J Clin Psychiatry 1994;55(9, suppl A):90-7. Betts TA. Depression, anxiety and epilepsy. In: Reynolds EH, Trimble MR, eds. Epilepsy and Psychiatry. Edinburgh: Churchill
and behavioural disorders: clinical descriptions and diagnostic
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and sfatistical
sorders. 4th Psychiatric Association, 1994.
of mental di
ton, DC: Americ
Spitzer RL, Endicott J, Robins E. Research diagnostic criteria. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1978;35:773-82.
Hamilton M. A rating scale for depression. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1960;23:56-62.
217, .Beck AT, Ward CH, Mendelson M, Mock J, Erbaugh J. An
inventory for measuring depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1961;
218. Pilowsky I, Levine S, Boulton DM. The classification of depres-
sion by numerical taxonomy. Br J Psychiatry 1969;115:93745. 219. Carney MWP, Roth M, Garside RF. The diagnosis of depressive syndromes and the prediction of ECT response. Br J Psychiarry
220 Blumer D. Epilepsy and disorders of mood. In: Smith DB,
Treiman DM, Trimble MR, eds. Neurobehavioral problems in
epilepsy. New York: Raven Press, 1991:185-95.
221. Blumer D, Montouris G, Hermann B. Psychiatric morbidity in seizure patients on a neurodiagnostic monitoring unit. The Jour- nal of Neuropsychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences 1995;7:445-
222. Ziegler RG. Impairments of control and competence in epileptic
children and their families. Epilepsia 1981;22:339-46.
223. Davis GR, Armstrong HE, Donovan DM, Ternkin NR. Cognitive- behavioural treatment of depressed affect amongst epileptics: pre-
liminary findings. J Clin Psychol 1984;4:930-5.
224. Gehlert S. Perceptions of control in adults with epilepsy. Epilep-
A textbook zyxpwo
ogy. Vol. 55 xwvutsrq
l. 10, 1999
of epilepsy. 4
zyxywxvwuv guidelines. Geneva: WHO, 1992.
M. V. LAMBERT AND M. M. ROBERTSON
225. Becli M, Becli N, Manzur G, Kochen S. Self-help epilepsy groups: an evaluation of effect on depression and schizophrenia. Epilepsia l993;34:841-5.
226. Jacoby A. Epilepsy and the quality of everyday life. Findings from a study of people with well-controlled epilepsy. Social Sci Med 1992;42:657-66.
227. Klerman GL. Treatment of recurrent unipolar major depressive disorder: commentary on the Pittsburgh Study. Arch Gen Psy- chiatry 1990;47:1158-61.
228. Kupfer DJ, Frank E, Perel JM. The advantage of early treatment intervention in recurrent depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1989; 46:771-5.
229. Tyrer P. Drug treatment of psychiatric patients in general prac- tice. BMJ 1978;2:1008-10.
230. Keller MB, Lavori PW, Klerman GL, et al. Low levels and lack of predictors of somatotherapy and psychotherapy received by depressed patients. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1986;43:458-68.
231. Prien RF, Kupfer DJ. Continuation drug therapy for major de- pressive episodes: how long should it be maintained? Am J Psy- chiatry 1986;143:18-23.
232. Blackwell B. MA01 interactions with other drugs. J Clin Neuro- pharmacol 1991;11:55-9.
252. Rapeport WG, Williams SA, Muirhead DC, Dewland PM, Tanner T. Wesnes K. Absence of a sertraline-mediated effect on the pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of carbamazepine. J Clin Psychiatry 1996;57(suppl 1):S2&3.
253. Andersen BB, Mikkelsen M, Vesterager A, et al. No influenceof the antidepressant paroxetine on carbamazepine, valproate and phenytoin. Epilepsy Res 1991:10:201 4 .
254. Grimsley SR, Jann MW, Carter JG, D’Mello AP, D’Souza MI. Increased carbamazepine plasma concentrations after fluoxetine coadministration. Clin Pharmacol Ther 1991;50:10-5.
255. Pearson HJ. Interaction of fluoxetine with carbamazepine [Let- ter]. J Clin Psychiatry 199051:126.
256. Gemaat HBPE, van de Woude J, Touw DJ. Fluoxetine and par- kinsonism in patients taking carbamazepine. Am J fsychiafv 1991;148:1604-5.
257. Fritze J, Unsorg B, Lanczik M. Interaction between carbamaze- pine and fluvoxamine. Acta Psychiatr Scand 1991;84:5834.
258. Martinelli V, Bocchetta A, Palmas AM, Del Zompo M. An in- teraction between carbamazepine and fluvoxamine. Br J Clin Pharmacol 1993;36:6154.
259. Joblin M. Possible interaction of sertraline with carbamazepine [Letter]. N Zeal Med J 1994;107:43.
233. Versiani M, Nardi AE, Figueira ILV, Stabl M. Tolerability of
moclobemide, a new reversible inhibitor of monoamine oxidase- A,comparedwithotherantidzepressantsyandplacebo.xActaPsy-w261.PisanviF,FazioAu,OteriG,ettal.Casrbamazepiner-viloxazqinein-p
chiatr Scand 1990;82(suppl 360):24-8. teraction on patients with epilepsy. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiu- 234. Davis JM, Glassman AH. Antidepressant drugs. In Kaplan HI, try 1986;49:1142-5.
of Psychiatry V
BJ, eds. C
S, Fuger J
. 5th 5.
235. Series HG. Drug treatment of depression in medically ill patients. amine or fluoxetine on plasma concentrations of carbamazepine
J Psychosom Res 1992;36:1-16. in epileptic patients. Pharmacol Res 1992;25(suppl 2):2145.
edition. Baltimore: Williams
fect of f luvox-
pressants. Drugs 1992;43:11-22. assessment of mirtazapine in the treatment of depression. Drug
, Moller HJ
ve efficacy of an
264. Kasper S
s. London: D
241. Ketter TA, Post RM, Parekh PI, Worthington K. Addition of by citalopram, fluoxetine, fluvoxamine and paroxetine. Eur J Cfin
man LS, Tolb
ert S. Elevated se
te) on psychom
blications, 1996. Dose-depen
260. Ashton AK, Wolin RE. Nefazodone-induced carbamazepine tox- icity. A m J Psychiarry 1996;153:733.
237. Swinkels JA, de Jonghe F. Safety of antidepressants. Int Clin Psychopharmacol 1995;9(suppl 4):19-25.
238.MontgomerySA.Rapzidonsetofyactionofvexnlafaxine.ZwntClinvonthedisupositionofmtirtazapisneinman.CrlinDruqgInvest1997p;o Psychopharmacol 1995a;lO(supp12):21-7. 13:37-46.
239. Robertson MM, Trimble MR. The treatment of depression in 266. Gailer JL, Edwards SM. SSRIs and anticonvulsants. Aust J Hosp patients with epilepsy. J Affect Disord 1985;9:127-36. Pharmacol 1996;26:587-8.
240. ABPI. Compendium
of data shee
maries of p
ts and sum
K, Loft S, P
HE, Brgsen K
270. Boyer WF, Blumhardt CL. The safety profile of paroxetine. Jour- nal of Clinical Psychiarry 1992;53(suppl 2):61-66.
271. Blacker R, Shanks NJ, Chapman N, Davey A. The drug treatment of depression in general practice: a comparison of nwte admin- istration of trazodone with mianserin, dothiepin and amitriptyline.
monoamineoxidaseinhibitorstocarhamazepine:preliminaryevi- Pharmacol 1996;51:73-8.
dence of safety and antidepressant efficacy in treatment-resistant 268. Brodie MJ. Drug interactions in epilepsy. Epilepsia 1992;
SUPPI PI 1 )
242. Amrein R, Guntert TW, Dingemanse J, Lorschied T, Stabl M, 269. Spina E, Pisani F, Perucca E. Clinically significant pharmacoki-
Schmid-Burgk W. Interactions of moclobemide with concomi- netic drug interactions with carbamazepine. An update. tantly administered medication: evidence from pharmacological Pharmacokinet 1996;31:198-214.
and clinical studies. Psychopharmacology 1992;106:S24-3 1.
243. Dursun SM, Matthew VM, Reveley MA. Toxic serotonin syn- drome after fluoxetine plus carbamazepine. Lancet 1993:342:
244. Nemeroff CB, De Vane CL, Pollock BG. Newer antidepressants
and the cytochrome P450 system. Am J Psychiatry 1996;153: Psychopharmacology 1988;95:S18-24.
311-20. 272. Hindmarch I, Alford C, Barwell F, Kerr JS. Measuring the side 245. Br6sen K. Recent developments in hepatic drug oxidation: im- effects of psychotropics: the behavioural toxicity of antidepres-
plications for clinical pharmacokinetics. Clin Pharmacokinet sants. J Psychopharmacol 1992;6:198-203.
246. Levy RH. Cytochrome P450 isoenzymes and antiepileptic drug drugs. JAMA 1980;244:1460-3.
276. Ruigt GSF, Kemp B, Groenhout CM, Kamphuisen HAC. Effect fluoxetine [Letter]. N Zeal Med J 1994;107:19. of the antidepressant ORG 3770 on human sleep. Eur J Clin
250. Shader RI, Greenblatt DJ, von Moltke LL. Fluoxetine inhibition Psychopharmacol 1990;38:551-4.
of phenytoin metabolism. J Cfin Psychopharmacol 1994;45: 277. Ramaekers JG, Muntjewerff ND, O’Hanlon JF. Acute and sub- 375-6. chronic effects of mirtazapine (15/30 mg nocte) and mianserin
er MB, Freed
nytoin concentrations associated with coadministration of sertra- and sleep in healthy, young volunteers. Eur Neuropsychophar-
line. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1997;17:107-9. macol 1995:6:294-5.
Epilepsia, Vol. 40, Suppl. 10, 1999
r N, Tausc
her J, Wolf R
265. Dahl ML, Voortman G, Alm C, et al. In vitro and in vivo studies
. Jeppesen U
, Gram LF, V
dent inhibition of CYPIA2, CYP2C 19 and CYP2D6
et al. No ef
. A risk-benef
nic side effec
274. Monti JM. Effect of a reversible monoamine oxidase A inhibitor (moclobemide) on sleep of depressed patients. Br J Psychiafry 1989;1 5 5 ( ~ ~ p6p):l61-5.
275. Armitage R, Rush AJ, Trivedi M, Cain J, Roffware HP. The effects of nefazodone on sleep architecture in depression. Neuro- psychopharmacology 1994;10:123-7.
interactions. Epilepsia 1995;36(suppl 5):S8-13.
247. Jalil P. Toxic reaction following the combined administration of fluoxetine and phenytoin: two case reports. J Neurol Neurosurg
248. Darley J. Interaction between phenytoin and fluoxetine. Seizure
249. Woods DJ, Coulter DM, Pillans P. Interaction of phenytoin and
ts of psychotro
DEPRESSION IN EPILEPSY s45 zy
278. Mattila M, Mattila MJ, Vrijmoed.de Vries M, Kuitunen T. Ac-
tions and interactions of psychotropic drugs on human perfor-
mance and mood: single doses of ORG 3770, amitriptyline and
mood. Pharmacol Toxic01 1989;65:81-8. Clin Psychiatry 1998;59(snppl 4):32-6.
venlafaxine for the treatment of major depression. J Clin Psycho- 308. Jick H, Dinan BJ, Hunter JR, et al. Tricyclic antidepressants and
pharmacol 1991;11:233-6. convulsions. J ClinPsychophamcol 1983;3:182-5.
281. Thompson PJ. Memory function in patients with epilepsy. In: 309. Forstl H, Pohlmann-Eden B. Monitoring antidepressant-induced
zyxM, eds. Neuw
J New M
284. Toone BK, Edeh J, Nanjee MN, Wheeler M. Hyposexuality and
epilepsy: a community survey of hormonal and behavioural
changes in male epileptics. Psychol Med 1989;19:937-43.
285. Jensen P, Jensen SB, Sorensen PS, et al. Sexual dysfunction in male and female patients with epilepsy: a study of 86 outpatients.
Arch Sexual Behav 1990;19:1-14.
286. Ndegwa D, Rust J, Golombok S, Fenwick P. Sexual problems in
epileptic women. Sex Marital Ther 1986,1:175-7.
287. Momell MJ, Guldner GT. Self-reported sexual function and sex- ual arousability in women with epilepsy. Epilepsia 1996;37:
288. Nofzinger EA, Thase Me, Reynold 111CF, et al. Sexual function
in depressed men: assessment by self report, behavioral and noc- turnal penile tumescence measures before and after treatment with cognitive behavior therapy. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1993;50: 24-30.
289. Margolese HC, Assalian P. Sexual side effects of antidepressants: a review. J Sex Marital Ther 1996;22:209-17.
290. Balon R, Yeragani VK, Pohl R, Ramesh C. Sexual dysfunction during antidepressant treatment. J Clin Psychiatry 1993;54:209- 12.
291. Warner MD, Peabody CA, Whiteford HA, Hollister LE. Traz- odone and priapism. J Clin Psychiatry 1987;48:2445.
292. Gitlin MJ. Psychotropic medications and their effects on sexual function: diagnosis, biology, and treatment approaches. J Clin Psychiatry 1994;55:406-13.
293. Baldwin D, Johnson FN. Tolerability and safety of citalopram.
Rev Contemp Pharmacother 1995;6:3 15-25.
294. Montgomery SA. Safety of mirtazapine: a review. Int Clin Psy- chophannacol 1995;IO(supp1 4 ) : 3 7 4 5 .
295. Klint T, Helsdingen JT. Lack of typical SSRI-related adverse effects and sexual dysfunction with mirtazapine is related to spe- cific blockade of 5-HT2 and 5-HT3 receptors [Abstract]. Eur Psy- chiarry 1996;l l(suppl 4):3475.
296. Rekers H, Kremer C, Zivkov M. Treatment with mirtazapine is not related to complaints of sexual dysfunction [Abstract]. Eur Neuropsychopharmacol 1996;6(suppl 3):47.
297. Stimmel GL, Dopheide JA, Stahl SM. Mirtazapine: an antide- pressant with noradrenergic and specific serotonergic effects. Pharmacology 1997;17:10-21.
298. Baldwin DS. Depression and sexual function. J Psychophannacol 1996;lO(supp1 1):30-4.
299. Phillip M, Kohnen R, Benkert 0. A comparison study of mo- clobemide and doxepin in major depression with special reference to effects on sexual dysfunction. Int J Clin Psychopharmacol i993;7:149-53.
300. Assalian P, Margolese HC. Treatment of antidepressant induced sexual side effects. J Sex Marital Ther 1996;22:218-24.
301. Brooke G, Weatherly JRC. Imipramine. Lancet 1959;2:568-9. 302. Rosenstein DL, Nelson JC, Jacobs SC. Seizures associated with
in epilepsy. Advances
y. Vol. 55.
. Peck AW
, Stern WC, W
Press, 1991:369-84. treatment with tricyclic antidepressant drugs and bupropion. J
282. Cole KD, Zarit SH. Psychological deficits in depressed medical Clin Psychiatry 1983;44(5 Pt 2):197-201.
283. Thompson PJ. Antidepressants and memory: a review. Hum Psy- and plasma drug concentration. J ClinPsychiatry 199233:160-2.
304. Davidson J. Seizures and bupropion: a review. J ClinPsychiafry 1989;50:256-61.
305. Settle EC Jr. Bupropion sustained release: side effect profile. J
279. Patris M, Bouchard J-M, Bougerol T, et al. Citalopram versus 306. Wroblewski BA, McColgan K, Smith K, et al. The incidence of fluoxetine: a double-blind, controlled, multicentre, phase 111trial seizures during tricyclic antidepressant drug treatment in a brain- in patients with unipolar major depression treated in general prac- injured population. J Clin Psychophamiacol 1990;10:124-8.
280. Schweizer E, Weise C, Clary C, et al. Placebo-controlled trial of zures. Phamcotherapy 1992;12:18-22.
cerebral hyperexcitability [Letter]. J Clin Psychiatry 1993;54:5. zyxwvtusrtqsrpqopo
d the risk of s
H, Fast G
wron DM, Sti
mmel GL. Ant
312. Ojemann LM, Friel PN, Trejo WJ, Dudley DL. Effect of doxepin on seizure frequency in depressed epileptic patients. Neurology
313. Magnus RV. A placebo controlled trial of viloxazine with and
without tranquilizers in depressive illness. J Inr Med Res 1975;
314. Meldrum BS, Anlezark GM, Adam HK, Greenwood DT. Anti-
convulsant and proconvulsant properties of viloxazine hydrochlo- ride: pharmacological and pharmacokinetic studies in rodents and the epileptic baboon. Psychopharmacology 1982;76:212.
315. Leyrie J. A special indication for viloxazine. Psychol Med 1981; 13:109.
316. Fromm GH, Wessel HB, Glass JD, Alvin JD, Van Horn G. Imip- ramine in absence and myoclonic-astatic seizures. Neurology 1978;28:797-804.
320. Deahl M, Trimble M. Serotonin reuptake inhibitors, epilepsy and myoclonus. Br J Psychiatry 1991;159:433-5.
321. Murthy R, Newton K, Qureshi J. The association of fluoxetine with seizures. J Psychophannacol I994;8:187-8.
322. Webber JJ. Seizure activity associated with fluoxetine therapy. CEin Pharm 1989;8:2968.
323. Ware MR, Stewart RB. Seizures associated with fluoxetine therapy [Letter]. Ann Pharmacother 1989;23:428.
324. Grady TA, Pigott TA, L’Heureux F, Murphy DL. Seizure asso- ciated with. fluoxetine and adjuvant buspirone therapy. J Clin Psychopharmacol 1992;12:7&71.
325. Wroblewski B, Guidos A, Leary JM, Joseph AB. Control of depression with fluoxetine and anti-seizure medication in a brain injured patient [Letter]. Am J Psychiatry 1992;149:273.
326. Prasher VP. Seizures associated with fluoxetine therapy. Seizure 1993;2:3 15-7.
327. Stembach H. Fluoxetine-clomiphene interaction. J Clin Psychia- try 1995;56:171-2.
328. Hargrave R, Martinez D, Bemstein AJ, Hayward CA. 1992. Fluoxetine-induced seizures. Psychosomatics 1992;33:236-7.
329. Gigli GL, Diornedi M, Troisi A, et al. Lack of potentiation of anticonvulsant effect by fluoxetine in drug-resistant epilepsy. Sei- zure 1994;3:221-4.
330. Levine R, Kenin M, Hoffman JS, Day KE. Grand ma1 seizures associated with the use of fluoxetine [Letter]. J Clin Psychophar- macol 1994;14145-6.
ester, Minnesota, 1935 through 1967. Epilepsia 1975;16:1-66. fluoxetine [Letter]. Am J Psychiatry 1990;147:948-9.
317. Tasini M. Complex partial seizures in a patient receiving traz- odone. J Clin Psychiatry 1986;47:318-9.
318. Wedin GP, Oderda GM, Klein-Schwartz W, et al. Relative tox- icity of cyclic antidepressants. Ann Emerg Med 1986;15:7.
antidepressants: a review. J Clin Psychiatry 1993;54:289-99. 303.HauserWA,KurlandLT.TheepidemiologyofepilepsyinRoch-332.CohenBJ,MahelskyM,AdlerL.MorecaseszofSIADHywithxw
depression and mania. In: Hardman JG, Limbird LE, Molinoff PB, Ruddon RW, and Gilrnan AG, eds. The pharmacological basis of therapeutics. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1996:431-59.
n C. Inci
the treatment o
33 1. Hwang AS, Magraw RM. Syndrome of inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone due to fluoxetine [Letter]. Am J Psychiatry 1989;146:399.
Epilepsia. Val. 4
dence of se
f psychiatric di
0, Suppl. 1
S,Jaber B, R
. M. ROBE
333. Goddard C, Paton C. Hyponatraemia associated with paroxetine and safety study of ORG 3770. Hum Psychopharmacol [Letter]. BMJ 1992;305:1332. 1995;101263-7 1.
fety of Med
patient treated with sertraline [Letter]. Am J Psychiatry 1993;150: tion of yellow card data. Medicines Control Agency, 1997.
334. Crews JR, Potts NLS, Schreiber J, Lipper
raemia in a
uch R. Moclob
newly developed product in the 1990s. J Clin Psychophannacol Topitz A. Effect of lithium on the EEG of healthy males and
388. Bell AJ, Cole A, Eccleston D, Ferrier IN. Lithium neurotoxicity
chopharmacol 1996;1O(suppl 1):11-7.
358. Richou Hz, Ruimy Py, Charbaut J, Delise JP, Brunner H, Patris M.
at normal therapeutic levels. Br J Psychiatry 1993;l62:689-92. 389. Devinsky 0,Duchowny MS. Seizures after convulsive therapy: a
Committee on Sa
nce on t
360. McConnell HW, Duncan D. Treatment of psychiatric comorbid- ity in epilepsy. In: McConnell HW, Snyder PJ, eds. Psvchiatric comorbidiry in epilepsy. Basic mechanisms, diagnosis, and treat- ment. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, 1998:245- 362.
335. Messiha FS. Fluoxetine: adverse effects and drug-drug interac-
tions. Clin Toxicol 1993;31:603-30.
336. Ball CJ, Herzberg J. Hyponatraemia and selective serotonin re-
uptake inhibitors. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 1994;9:819-22.
337. FlintAJ,CrosbyJ,GenikJL.Recurrenthyponatraemiaassociated with fluoxetine and paroxetine [Letter]. Am J Psychiatry 1996;
338. Goldstein L, Barker M, Segall F, et al. Seizure and transient
SIADH associated with sertraline [Letter]. Am J Psychiatry 1996;
339. Voegeli J, Baumann P. Inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic
hormone and SSRIs. Br J Psychaitry 1996;169:524-5.
340. Bouman WP, Johnson H, Pinner G. Inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion and SSRIs. Br J Psychiatry 1997;170:88-89.
341.BoumanW,PinnerG,JohnsonH.Incidenceofselectivesero- tonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) induced hyponatraemia due to the syndrome of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone (SIADH) secre- tion in the elderly. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 1998;13:12-5.
342. Committee on Safety of Medicines. Antidepressant-induced hy- ponatraemia. Curr Probl Phannacovigilance 1994;20:5-6.
343. Liu BA, Mittmann N, Knowles SR, Shear NH. Hyponatraemia
and the syndrome of inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hor- mone associated with the use of selective serotonin reuptake in- hibitors: a review of spontaneous reports. J Can Med Assoc 1996; 155:5 19-27,
344. Kalff R, Houtkooper MA, Meyer JWA, Goedhart DM, Augus- teijn R, Meinardi H. Carbamazepine and serum sodium levels. Epilepsia 1984;25:390-7.
345. Leander JD. Fluoxetine, a selective serotonin-uptake inhibitor, enhances the anticonvulsant effects of phenytoin, carbamazepine and ameltolide (LY201116). Epilepsia 1992;33:573-6.
346. Favale E, Rubino V, Mainardi P, Lunardi G, Albano C. Anticon- vulsant effect of fluvoxamine in humans. Neurology 1995;45: 1926-7.
347. Troisi A, Vicario E, Nuccetelli F, Ciani N, Pasini A. Effects of fluoxetine on aggressive behaviour of adult inpatients with men- tal retardation and epilepsy. Pharmacopsychiatry 1995;28:734.
348. Wernicke JF. The side effect profile and safety of fluoxetine. J Clin Psychiatry 1985;46:59-67.
349. Harmant J, van Rijckevorsel-Harmant K, De Barsy Th, Hen- drickx B. Fluvoxamine: an antidepressant with low (or no) epi- leptogenic effect [Letter]. Lancet 1990;2:386.
350. Sedgewick EM, Cilasun J, Edwards JG. Paroxetine and the elec- troencephalogram. J Clin Psychophannacol 1987;1:314.
351. ChandlerLP,RasmussenJGC.Analysisofseizurepotentialinthe sertraline, placebo, and active control groups in the sertraline development program [Abstract]. Clin Neurophannacol 1992; 15(suppl 1B):317B.
352. Lader M, Melhuish A, Frcka G, Fredricson Over0 K, Christensen V. The effects of citalopram in single and repeated doses and with alcohol on physiological and psychological measures in healthy subjects. Eur J Clin Pharmacol 1986;31:183-90.
353. Blumer D. Antidepressant and double antidepressant treatment for the affective disorder of epilepsy. J Clin Psychiatry 1997;58: 3-11.
354. Edwards JG, Wheal HV. Assessment of epileptogenic potential: experimzental,clinicalyandepidemioxlogicalapproawches.JPhar-v385.JuuliusSC,BrentnerRP.Myocslonicseizuresrwithlithium.qBiolp macol 1992;6:204-13. Psychiatry 1987;22:1184-90.
355. Danjou P, Hackett D. Safety and tolerance profile of venlafaxine. 386. Rosen RB, Stevens R. Action myoclonus in lithium toxicity. Ann Int Clin Psychopharmacol 1995;10(suppl 2): 15-20. Neurol 1983;13:221-2.
357. Marcus RN. Safety and tolerability profile of nefazodone. J Psy-
362. Frommer DA, Kulig KW, Marx JA, Rumack B. Tricyclic anti- depressant overdose: a review. JAMA 1987;257:5214.
363. Hulten BA, Heath A. Clinical aspects of tricyclic antidepressant poisoning. Acta Med Scand 1983;213:275-8.
361. Dailey JW, Naritoku DK. Antidepressants and seizures: clinical
anecdotes overshadow neuroscience. Biochem Pharmacol
364. Buckley NA, Dawson AH, Whyte IM, Henry DA. Greater icity in overdose of dothiepin than of other tricyclic antidepres- sants. Lancet 1994;343:159452.
365. Knudsen K,Heath A. Effects of self poisoning with maprotiline. BMJ 1984;288:601-3.
366. Wyss PA, Serena S, Meier PJ. Dose-dependency of seizures in maprotiline (Ludiomil) intoxications [Abstract]. Veterin Hum Toxicol 1993;35:341.
367. Litovitz TL, Troutman WG. Amoxapine overdose. JAMA 1983; 250:1069-7 1.
368. Personne M, Persson H, Sjoberg G. Citalopram toxicity. Lancet 1997;350:5 18-9.
369. Cassidy S.Henry J. Fatal toxicity of antidepressant drugs in over- dose. BMJ 1987;295:10214.
370. Deleted in proof.
citalopram. Lancet 1996;348:339-40.
373. Glassman AH. Citalopram toxicity. Lancet 1997;350:818.
374. Shukla S,Mukherjee S, Decina P. Lithium in the treatment of
375. Lyketsos CG, Stoline AM, Longstreet P, et al. Mania in temporal
lobe epilepsy. Neuropsychiatry Neuropsq.cho1 Behav Neurol
376. Schou M, Amdisen A, Trap-Jensen J. Lithium poisoning. Am J
377. Wharton RN.Grand ma1 seizures with lithium treatment. Am J
378. Spring GK. EEG observations in confirming neurotoxicity [Let-
ter]. Am J Psychiatry 1979;136:1099-100.
379. S h a r d M, Gumbiner B, Lee A, et al. Lithium carbonate intoxi-
cation. A case report and review of the literature. Arch h e m Med 198%1943tW6.
380. demers R, Lukesh R, Prichard J. Convulsion during lithium therapy [Letter]. Lancet 2:3156.
381. Baldessarini RJ,Stephens JH. Lithium carbonate for affective disorders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1970;22:72-7.
382. Jus A, Villeneuve A, Gauthier J, et al. Influence of lithium car- bonate on patients with temporal lobe epilepsy. Can J Psychiaty 1973;18:77-8.
383. Moore DP. A case of petit ma1 epilepsy aggravated by lithium. Am J Psychiazry 1981;138:690-1.
bipolar disorders associated with epilepsy: an open study. J
384. Massey EW, Folger WN. Seizures activated by therapeutic levels of lithium carbonate. South Med J 1984;77:1173-5.
au K, Rappels
berger P, Lov
A multicenter double-blind, clomipramine-controlled efficacy retrospective case survey. Neurology 1983;33:921-5.
Epiiepsra, Vol. 4
0, Suppl. 1
rek A, Petsch
e H, Simhandl
lographic findings following shock therapy. J Nerv Men? 1955;122:581-8.
392. Blackwood DHR, Cull RE, Freeman CPL, Evans JI, Maudsley C. A study of the incidence of epilepsy following ECT. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1980;43:1098-102.
393. Hsiao JK, Messenheimer JA, Evans DL. ECT and neurological disorders. Convulsive Ther 1987;3:121-36.
394. Freeman CPL. ECT and other physical therapies. In: Kendell RE, Zealley AK, eds. Companion to psychiatric studies. 5th ed. Ed- inburgh: Churchill-Livingstone, 1993:84747.
HJ.ECT as a t
s and related
DEPRESSION IN EPILEPSY s4
390. Grogan R, Wagner DR, Sullivan T, Labar D. Generalised non- 395. Kalinowsky LB, Kennedy F. Observation in electroshock therapy convulsive status epilepticus after electroconvulsive therapy. applied to the problems of epilepsy. J Nerv Ment Dis 1943;98:
Convulsive Ther 1995;11:51-6.
397. Krystal AD, Weiner RD. ECT seizure adequacy. Convulsive Tiler 1993;10:153-64.
398. Weiner RD, Coffey CE. Electroconvulsive therapy in the medical and neurologic patient. In: Stoudemire A, Fogel BS, eds. Psychi- atric care of the medical patient. New York: Oxford University Press, 1993:207-24.
396. Keller CH, Bernstein
ness. In: Coffey CE, ed. The clinical science
therapy. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, 1993: 183-210.
reatment for ne
Epilepsia. Vol.40,Suppl. 10,1999